Destination-worthy tavern-style pies with a quirky, vinyl-spun vibe; expect counter ordering, waits at peak times, and higher-than-expected prices for personal pies.
Good Times excels with exceptional tavern-style pizza execution—crispy crust, balanced toppings, and ingredient-forward care that justifies its loyal following. However, occasional quality variation with burnt bottoms and peak-hour waits stretching 35–45 minutes prevent grade A territory. The charming vinyl-fueled setting and strong neighborhood reputation deliver solid value for a casual pizza spot, making it competitive with the area's better neighborhood restaurants.
One caveat: Waits of 30–45 minutes at peak and limited seats