A neighborhood Japanese spot with consistently praised freshness, broad poke and sushi choices, and reasonable prices, though the small dining room and occasional delivery or portion problems warrant realistic expectations.
Poke Ici delivers strong food quality with consistently fresh ingredients and reliable execution that keeps customers returning, but its compact, modest setting and uneven delivery performance prevent a higher grade. The neighborhood convenience and friendly service create a solid casual dining experience, though it lacks the polish or destination appeal that would elevate it further.
Poke Ici feels like a practical neighborhood favorite in Pointe-Saint-Charles: a small, casual room backed by a much larger takeout and delivery reputation. Regulars describe it as a dependable nearby stop, with the prevailing impression summed up as fresh food, friendly people, and prices that do not sting. The room can feel cramped, and nearby construction has occasionally made the arrival less charming. The menu is broader and more playful than a traditional sushi counter, moving from salmon and tuna poke to katsu bowls, kimchi, Korean fried chicken, tempura-heavy rolls, sushi pizzas, tartare, and shareable platters. Freshness is the clear headline, with salmon poke, chicken katsu poke, vegetarian bowls, and mixed sushi plates earning the most consistent praise. Delivery is the weak link: a handful of diners report waits, missing or incorrect items, small portions, or frozen fish, while the much larger body of feedback describes satisfying food. Families should have plenty to work with: salmon poke, chicken katsu, shrimp tempura, California rolls, simple hosomaki, rice-based platters, and several vegetarian bowls are all on the current menu. One reviewer specifically reports a child finishing a salmon bowl, while another ordered a vegetarian squash-and-black-bean bowl for a parent. It is a good casual family option, though the small dining room and occasional delivery inconsistency favor pickup or a short meal over a leisurely gathering.
Area vibe: Busy commercial and transit-oriented downtown core known for shopping, offices, and restaurants.
Safety: Generally safe with good lighting and steady foot traffic, though typical urban precautions at night apply.
What's nearby: Close to metro stations, Concordia University campuses, Sainte-Catherine Street shopping, and a dense restaurant/retail strip.