Seemor
Nantucket › Nantucket › The Proprietors Bar & Table
The Proprietors Bar & TableA-Worth Trying
9 India St, Nantucket, MA 02554
· American restaurant, Bar
· 4.4/5 Google (267 reviews)
Reservations · Outdoor seating
Creative New American small plates with standout cocktails and desserts in a cozy downtown house; excellent food and vibe but portions run small and pricing is a splurge.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
The Proprietors Bar & Table delivers exceptional food quality through creative, globally-influenced small plates and memorable desserts, supported by professional, knowledgeable service in a charming historic setting. However, some consistency variation, modest space comfort, and occasional pacing concerns prevent grade A territory. Strong execution across core dimensions makes it competitive with the area's better neighborhood restaurants, though premium pricing and small portions require aligned expectations.
Restaurant Summary
Set inside a historic downtown house, the room feels warm and cozy with a lively bar and vintage touches. Guests describe staff as professional and helpful, guiding them through a menu built for sharing. One diner put it simply: "We ordered a handful of small plates and everything was incredible." Pricing is a splurge for Nantucket, and portions tend to be petite, so expectations matter. The cooking leans contemporary and globally influenced, a creative small-plates approach where vegetable-forward ideas sit beside crudo, tartare, and a beloved roast chicken. Flavors pull from the Middle East, France, and Asia without theatrics, and the pastry team turns out memorable desserts like lemon meringue ice cream. Cocktails are destination-worthy, though some find pre-batched pours less showy than expected. For families, it is more adult-oriented. There is no kids menu mentioned, and dishes like monkfish, tartare, and sambal broccoli skew adventurous. That said, items such as the roast chicken, gemelli pasta, and occasional burger provide kid-friendlier anchors if your crew is flexible.
At a Glance
- Creative, globally influenced small plates with standout desserts
- Charming house setting and knowledgeable service
- Portions are small relative to price; plan to share several dishes
- Pacing can feel rushed when multiple plates fire at once
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- inventive_veg_forward_small_plates
- destination_cocktail_program
- memorable_housemade_desserts
What People Love
- Inventive flavors that surprise without gimmicks
- Desserts that end the night on a high note
- A cozy, vintage setting that feels special
- Attentive staff who guide the menu
Points of Concern
- Portions frequently described as small; some guests leave hungry without multiple courses
- Premium pricing can surprise; cocktails and small plates run high
- Pacing issues reported when several small plates arrive at once
- Review patterns are consistent with potential coordination (high five-star share, some marketing language) which may not reflect typical diner experience
- Limited options for conservative palates or picky eaters
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$85-$120 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Begin with hummus with zhoug and fried broccoli to gauge spice tolerance
- Share one Bigs (roast chicken or monkfish) to anchor the meal
- Plan a dessert; the lemon meringue ice cream is a frequent favorite
Perfect For
- Date night with a foodie twist
- Cocktail-forward dinners with friends
- Seasonal tasting of inventive small plates
- Celebrations for adventurous eaters
Location Insights
Area: Quaint historic downtown with boutique shops and upscale dining; strong seasonal tourist flow.
Safety: Well-lit, high foot traffic, generally very safe, especially in season.
Nearby: Near Main Street shops, galleries, and other destination restaurants; walkable from ferry area.
Nantucket TownNantucket Town is the main commercial and cultural hub of the island, featuring a mix of boutique shops, galleries, and a diverse range of restaurants. The dining scene here is sophisticated yet relaxed, often emphasizing fresh seafood and contemporary American cuisine, attracting both visitors and locals seeking quality dining experiences.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday17:00–23:30
Tuesday17:00–23:30
Wednesday
Thursday17:00–23:30
Friday17:00–23:30
Saturday17:00–23:30
Sunday17:00–23:30
Available: Reservations, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →