Seemor

Cape Cod / Nantucket › Nantucket

Best Restaurants in Nantucket

15 restaurants analyzed · Cape Cod / Nantucket

Nantucket has a dining scene that substantially outperforms its size, with an above-average share of top-rated American and seafood restaurants for a town of 60-odd places. Prices lean toward the higher end - nearly 40% of restaurants sit in the very expensive bracket - but the quality at the top is real and would hold up in any major city. The cobblestone streets off the waterfront hold some of the best spots.

Grade Distribution

Restaurants

• The Seagrille A · Seafood restaurant, Raw bar — Creative, high-quality New England seafood with polished service and steep prices; reserve ahead and expect a...
• The Proprietors Bar & Table A- · American restaurant, Bar — Creative New American small plates with standout cocktails and desserts in a cozy downtown house; excellent food and...
• The Nautilus B+ · Restaurant, Cocktail bar — Destination-worthy Asian-fusion small plates with standout duck and crab fried rice, lively bar energy, and tough...
• Brant Point Grill B+ · Seafood & Grill, Steakhouse — Waterfront views and polished service shine; food ranges from good to middling at very expensive prices, best for...
• Brotherhood of Thieves B+ · Restaurant, Bar — A lively historic pub-restaurant with a broad American menu plus sushi, strong seafood and burgers, bustling service...
• Lemon Press l Restaurant, Catering & Private Event Space B+ · Restaurant, Cafe — Creative Mediterranean-leaning brunch and all-day spot with lively vibes and standout Persian-influenced dishes; expect...
• Kitty Murtagh's B+ · Irish pub, Restaurant — Lively neighborhood Irish pub with hearty classics, big pretzels, and a kid-friendly menu; expect solid comfort food,...
• or, The Whale B+ · Restaurant, Bar — Stylish downtown spot with creative, seafood-forward American plates and a lively patio; standout duck carnitas and...
• B-ACK Yard BBQ B+ · Barbecue restaurant, American — Solid island BBQ with standout brisket sandwiches and loaded nachos, lively bar, and gluten-free awareness; occasional...
• Island Kitchen | Restaurant & Catering B+ · American restaurant, Breakfast & brunch — Sunny mid-island brunch-and-more hub with strong breakfast, friendly service, and house ice cream; occasional slow or...
• Sayle's Seafood B · Seafood market with takeout, Seafood restaurant — Casual dockside market turning out very fresh fried and steamed seafood at fair island prices, with limited outdoor...
• GypSea Café B · Cafe, Breakfast — Sunny, counter-order beachside cafe serving crowd-pleasing breakfast and lunch with exceptionally friendly owner-led...
• Stubbys B- · Counter-service American, Breakfast — Busy counter-service staple for quick breakfasts, burgers, fried seafood, and Jamaican plates with late-night hours;...
• BOAT HOUSE B- · Counter-service casual, Takeout — Large-portioned bowls, burritos, burgers, and Jamaican plates at moderate prices; fast counter service shines, though...
• Cisco Brewers B- · Brewery and outdoor venue, Distillery — Destination brewery campus with live music, multiple bars, and food trucks; fantastic vibe but can be crowded with...

Top Cuisines

• American — 9 restaurants
• Seafood — 3 restaurants
• Contemporary Asian — 1 restaurants
• Mediterranean — 1 restaurants
• Irish — 1 restaurants

Find Your Next Meal in Nantucket

• Casual Meal restaurants in Nantucket — Quick, quality, no fuss
• Date Night restaurants in Nantucket — Romantic dining for two
• Fun with Friends restaurants in Nantucket — Something everyone will enjoy
• Family Outing restaurants in Nantucket — Kid-friendly, stress-free dining
• Solo Dining restaurants in Nantucket — Comfortable spots for dining alone
• Business Discussion restaurants in Nantucket — Professional setting, no distractions
• Vegetarian-Friendly restaurants in Nantucket
• Vegan-Friendly restaurants in Nantucket
• Gluten-Free Friendly restaurants in Nantucket
• Walk-ins Welcome restaurants in Nantucket
• Private Dining restaurants in Nantucket
• Local Gems restaurants in Nantucket
• Easy Parking restaurants in Nantucket
• Amazing Setting restaurants in Nantucket
• Great Value restaurants in Nantucket

Explore Nantucket on Seemor →