A charming, family-friendly New Holland diner pairing dependable soups and sandwiches with standout ice cream and a nostalgic setting, though a minority of diners question portion value and occasional service consistency.
Lickity Split delivers solid food quality across its core offerings of soups, sandwiches, and ice cream, supported by attentive service and a charming, nostalgic setting that draws visitors during local outings. Consistency holds steady across repeat visits, though occasional preparation lapses and modest service knowledge keep it just short of the very top tier. The experience feels dependable and welcoming rather than exceptional.
Lickity Split is a warm, old-fashioned Main Street stop where historic decor, small-town hospitality, and a peaceful diner atmosphere set the tone. Reviewers describe an antique building filled with character, friendly table service, and the satisfying feeling of discovering a local favorite while exploring New Holland or Lancaster County. One recurring impression is that lunch here feels like a charming trip back to the soda-fountain era. The cooking is casual and familiar, centered on homemade soups, sandwiches, wraps, salads, Pennsylvania Dutch-influenced specials, and a substantial ice-cream program. The creamy dill-pickle soup is the clear conversation starter, while waffle sundaes, unusual seasonal flavors, and the Thanksgiving sandwich give the menu personality without becoming overly formal or experimental. Most diners find the food delicious and carefully prepared, although a few guests have found particular portions small or certain items underwhelming. Families are especially well served: the current kids menu includes grilled cheese, hot dog, build-your-own sandwich, mac and cheese, PB&J, sides, a drink, and an optional petite ice cream. That menu reality supports the family-friendly reputation, and the dessert counter is an easy win for children. Picky eaters should have several safe choices, while adventurous adults can try the pickle soup or specialty sundaes.
Area vibe: Quaint, agricultural county with historic small towns and a relaxed pace.
Safety: Generally safe, low crime, quiet streets with limited late-night activity.
What's nearby: Near New Holland's Main Street shops, local businesses, Lynnwood Theater and agricultural businesses; accessible via local roads.
Expect a charming, relaxed stop rather than a perfectly predictable one, with occasional slow service and mixed portion-value feedback.
The setting leans nostalgic and peaceful, pairing historic Main Street character with a family-friendly ice-cream stop.
The dill-pickle soup and Pennsylvania Dutch-inspired plates are the savory standouts, but the dessert menu deserves serious attention too.