A welcoming New Milford Italian restaurant with especially strong pizza, generous portions, and family-friendly pricing, though peak-time waits, tight parking, and occasional service or consistency lapses are worth planning around.
Brickhouse Pizza & Restaurant delivers solid food quality across pizza, pasta, and seafood with strong service attentiveness that keeps diners returning regularly. Competitive pricing and generous portions reinforce its appeal as a dependable neighborhood spot, though the casual, family-oriented setting lacks the distinctive character or consistency that would elevate it further.
Brickhouse feels like the kind of local Italian room where the pizza counter is busy, the dining room stays warm and casual, and regulars seem to know exactly what they want. Reviewers describe a cozy, rustic atmosphere and genuinely welcoming staff; one recurring impression is that the smell of baking pizza and Italian cooking makes pickup customers rethink taking dinner home. The kitchen leans classic Italian-American rather than experimental: thin-crust pizza, familiar pasta, seafood over linguine, chicken classics, grinders, and generous family-style portions. Pizza is the headline act, with pasta and dishes such as chicken Francese, shrimp preparations, and ravioli providing credible alternatives. Most feedback is enthusiastic, though an older repeat customer reports a persistent decline in pizza execution and a few diners encountered slow or poorly recovered service during busy periods. Families are particularly well served: the menu includes children's spaghetti marinara, ravioli, meatball or sausage sides, personal pizza, chicken tenders, and many approachable pasta dishes. Reviews specifically mention children loving spaghetti and meatballs and enjoying the casual setting. It is an easy choice for family dinners, including picky eaters, while gluten-free diners have both pizza and pasta options; confirm preparation practices directly for severe allergies.
Area vibe: Small-town New England market town with historic shops, civic institutions, and suburban residential pockets.
Safety: Generally safe, quiet streets with good evening lighting in downtown and low crime typical of suburban Connecticut.
What's nearby: Near New Milford town center, Route 7 (Danbury Rd), local shops, schools, and riverfront parks.
The thin-crust pizza is the main attraction, but Chicken Francese, seafood pastas, and family-friendly ravioli are strong alternatives.
Expect a relaxed family setting, but plan around peak-time delays, difficult parking, and occasional inconsistency in service and pizza execution.
The room feels cozy and welcoming, with a lively pizza-counter energy that becomes more hectic during peak periods.