Seemor

$1.50 Fresh PizzaC+Worth Trying

Name: $1.50 Fresh Pizza
Address: 143 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018, New York, United States
Rating: 4.5

143 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018 · Pizza restaurant, Fast food restaurant, Pizza delivery · 4.5/5 Google (2630 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout

Ultra-cheap New York slices with fast counter service; great for a quick bite, but expect crowds, standing only, occasional overcharge complaints, and mixed hygiene/service reports.

Why it gets a C+ for overall quality

$1.50 Fresh Pizza delivers what it promises: hot, foldable slices at unbeatable Midtown prices with exceptional service speed that keeps lines moving. However, food safety complaints and quality variation between slices prevent a higher grade, while the standing-only, cramped space limits appeal beyond quick grab-and-go visits. Best suited for budget-conscious diners prioritizing value and speed over comfort or reliability.

Restaurant Summary

A narrow counter spot near Times Square where the draw is hot, foldable slices and the line that somehow flies. Expect brusque, efficient counter service, standing ledges, and a price board that keeps value hunters coming back. One diner summed it up: "faster than the fancy places" and easier on the wallet. The cooking is classic slice-joint fare with a no-frills approach: basic cheese or pepperoni, with some toppings added after-the-fact and finished in the oven. The culinary approach leans traditional and value-driven rather than creative, best for people who want simple New York pizza without the fanfare. Families do fine here thanks to plain cheese slices, quick service, and combo deals that stretch a budget. There is no seating, only standing shelves, and it can be crowded, so strollers and long linger sessions are tough. Kids who like cheese or pepperoni will have straightforward options.

At a Glance

Exceptional value on slices and combos for Midtown
Very fast service even with lines
Standing-only, cramped space
Reports of overcharges and price confusion
Mixed hygiene and occasional food safety complaints

What Sets It Apart

ultra_low_price_point
fast_turnover_hot_slices
prime_midtown_location

What People Love

That it is hot and ready fast
Classic foldable NY slice feel
Two-slice combo deals
Cheaper than famous shops nearby

Points of Concern

Standing-only and tight quarters get crowded at peak times
Recurring complaints about overcharging or mismatched signage
Service can be brusque or unfriendly under pressure
Hygiene and a few illness reports suggest caution during off-peak holds

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost$5-$9 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Stick to cheese or pepperoni for best consistency
Use the two-slice combo for maximum value
Order whole cheese pie if feeding 3-4 on a tight budget

Perfect For

Grabbing a quick slice between shows
Late-night budget bite near Times Square
Solo snack on the go
Feeding a group cheaply with a whole pie

Location Insights

Area: High-traffic Midtown block serving commuters and tourists; quick-bite oriented with budget options.

Safety: Busy, well-lit corridors; gritty at times near Port Authority with typical urban issues.

Nearby: Near Times Square, theaters, Port Authority, hotels, and office towers; heavy foot traffic day and night.

Garment DistrictThe Garment District is characterized by a mix of commercial office buildings, showrooms, and a vibrant dining scene catering to professionals and visitors. The area offers a variety of casual and upscale dining options, often busy during lunch and dinner hours with a dynamic, fast-paced atmosphere.

nullnull

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday09:30–05:00 Tuesday09:30–05:00 Wednesday09:30–05:00 Thursday09:30–05:00 Friday09:30–05:00 Saturday09:30–05:00 Sunday09:30–04:30

Available: Delivery, Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →