Seemor

Queens › Richmond Hill › Alfie's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Alfie's Pizzeria & RestaurantC

86-08 117th St, Richmond Hill, NY 11418 · Pizza restaurant, Delivery Restaurant · Richmond Hill

Neighborhood pizzeria with beloved Sicilian and upside-down pies, friendly family-run vibe, budget pricing, but quality can be inconsistent and it is cash only.

Our take

Alfie's Pizzeria excels with standout Sicilian and upside-down pies that inspire decades of loyalty, backed by genuinely friendly service and exceptional value. However, inconsistent execution on delivery and occasional quality lapses prevent a stronger grade, while the dated interior and basic seating lack the appeal needed to elevate the experience.

One caveat: Quality can swing from excellent to undercooked or burnt depending on timing and order channel

Standout dishes

• Sicilian Pie
• Upside Down Pie
• Grandma Slice

What people love

• Nostalgic neighborhood vibe
• Sicilian and upside-down slices with fresh-tasting sauce
• Friendly, jokey counter service

Opening Hours

See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →