Lively neighborhood Mexican spot with standout margaritas, good tacos and creative touches, but prices and portions draw mixed reactions; best for drinks-plus-small-plates over a full feast.
Bar San Miguel delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by standout dishes like miso black cod and short rib tacos, paired with exceptional service hospitality and a charming backyard setting. The contemporary Mexican approach with creative flourishes and impressive cocktail program elevates it above typical neighborhood spots, though modest portions and occasional consistency dips in execution prevent grade A territory. Reliable execution and loyal following make it a competitive neighborhood destination in Carroll Gardens.
One caveat: Portions described as small by some guests, especially tacos