Seemor
Bedstuy Mike's PizzaB-Worth Trying
905 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11206
· Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Pizza Takeout
· 4.4/5 Google (339 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Solid neighborhood slice joint with budget-friendly prices and quick service; best for classic slices over pastas or complex orders.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Bedstuy Mike's Pizza delivers reliable neighborhood slice-shop quality with strong cheese pizza execution and friendly, efficient service at fair prices. However, inconsistent prep on specialty items and occasional order errors prevent a higher grade, while the functional corner-shop setting lacks destination appeal. Best experienced as a casual, no-frills local go-to for classic slices rather than a comprehensive dining destination.
Restaurant Summary
This corner spot plays it classic slice-joint casual with friendly, fast service and prices that feel kind to the wallet. Think thin, slightly crunchy crusts and a steady stream of locals grabbing slices. One diner summed it up simply: "the cheese slice hit the spot," a refrain echoed by folks calling it a neighborhood gem. The cooking leans traditional NYC pizza over chef-y moves. Stick to the cheese and margherita for the most consistent wins; toppings and non-pizza items can be uneven. Delivery pies occasionally skew underbaked, and a few orders arrived missing components like sauce on a Hawaiian, so manage expectations on off-peak categories. For families, this is an easy fit: regular and Sicilian slices, garlic knots, fries, and mozzarella sticks are kid-pleasers. No dedicated kids menu is needed given the familiar lineup, though adventurous pasta orders are riskier. Grab slices at the counter, find a seat if available, and keep it simple for the best results.
At a Glance
- Classic cheese slice draws consistent praise
- Budget-friendly pricing for NYC
- Inconsistent prep on delivery and some specialty items
- Occasional order errors or missing components
- Pasta and Alfredo reports are weak compared to pizza
What Sets It Apart
- reliable_neighborhood_slice
- fast_counter_service
- budget_pricing
What People Love
- That first-bite NYC slice nostalgia
- Fast, friendly counter service
- Good prices for the area
- Crunchy-thin crust on cheese slices
Points of Concern
- Quality control can slip on delivery pies (undercooked crust reports)
- Some items arrive missing components (e.g., no sauce on a Hawaiian pie)
- Non-pizza items like chicken Alfredo and some rolls get poor feedback
- Pricing confusion perceived by a few first-timers; stick to posted slice/pie prices
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$14-$20 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose a cheese slice ($4.25) or Sicilian ($5.00) for best value
- Whole cheese pie (~$13) feeds 3-4 on a budget
- Heroes/pasta ($12-$17) are available but not strengths
Perfect For
- Quick solo lunch near Myrtle Ave
- Casual weeknight pizza fix
- Late-night slice stop
- Feeding a group with affordable pies
Location Insights
Area: Busy mixed-use Bed-Stuy stretch with foot traffic, commuters, and locals seeking quick eats.
Safety: Generally fine with regular foot traffic; standard urban awareness advised, especially late nights.
Nearby: Surrounded by bodegas, small shops, and residences; convenient for grab-and-go meals.
BushwickBushwick is known for its thriving arts scene, industrial-chic vibe, and a growing number of trendy restaurants and bars. The dining environment is eclectic, featuring everything from innovative eateries and craft breweries to traditional Latin American and Caribbean spots, reflecting the neighborhood's diverse population. The area is popular among younger crowds seeking a hip, urban atmosphere with a strong community feel.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–22:00
Tuesday11:00–22:00
Wednesday11:00–22:00
Thursday11:00–22:00
Friday11:00–22:00
Saturday11:00–22:00
Sunday11:30–21:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →