Seemor
Broadway PizzaB+Worth Trying
1142 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.7/5 Google (806 reviews)
Takeout
Neighborhood slice shop turning out tasty NY-style pies with friendly, fast counter service and budget-friendly combos; expect great margherita and solid heroes, with occasional complaints about salad quality and premium slice pricing.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Broadway Pizza delivers reliable neighborhood pizza shop excellence through strong food quality anchored by praised margherita and cheese slices, paired with friendly, unhurried service and exceptional speed. The solid consistency on core pies supports its loyal following, though occasional misses on non-pizza items and modest casual ambiance prevent grade A territory. A dependable local favorite that exceeds typical slice shop standards.
Restaurant Summary
A neighborhood slice shop near the J line where the ovens keep the pies coming and the counter crew stays friendly and fast. Reviewers rave about the margherita and classic cheese slices, with one noting the sauce had a gentle sweetness and a perfect balance. The room is clean and casual; people pop in for a quick bite, and staff often show unhurried hospitality even near closing. The cooking leans traditional New York pie shop over frills: thin crusts, classic toppings, and a long list of heroes, pastas, and budget combos. Expect comforting, familiar flavors rather than culinary experiments; the value sits in big slices and reliable execution. Fans praise the pies consistently, though a few report salty non-pizza items or the occasional mix-up on baked pasta orders. For families, this is easy mode: cheese or pepperoni slices, personal pies with a drink, chicken fingers, fries, and simple pastas. There is no dedicated kids menu, but the offerings are very kid-friendly. If your crew prefers plain cheese over adventurous toppings, steer to the cheaper slices; specialty slices can cost more than expected.
At a Glance
- Excellent margherita and classic cheese slices with balanced sauce
- Friendly, fast counter service and clean space
- Big, filling slices and value-forward combos
- Premium/specialty slices around $7 feel pricey to some
- Occasional misses on salads, fries, and baked pasta accuracy
What Sets It Apart
- excellent_margherita_execution
- big_filling_slices
- broad_menu_with_value_combos
What People Love
- Balanced, flavorful sauce on margherita and cheese slices
- Warm, patient service that does not rush you
- Clean, straightforward space focused on the food
- Portions that leave you full without overspending
Points of Concern
- Premium/specialty slices can run about $7, surprising some diners
- Salads and fries draw mixed feedback with occasional saltiness or inconsistency
- One-off order accuracy issues on baked ziti reported
- Winter comfort may vary; one mention of heat not working during a visit
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$15-$24 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For the best value, pair a personal cheese pie (#24 $11.50) with a friend and add garlic knots ($3.00).
- Hero fans: Meatball Parmigiana ($12.00) delivers classic comfort without premium pricing.
- Pasta lovers: Baked Ziti & Mozzarella ($12.95) is the safest priced pick; verify preparation when ordering.
Perfect For
- Grabbing a fast, satisfying slice before the J train
- Casual weeknight dinner with value combos
- Solo lunch at the counter or outside
- Feeding kids who want familiar pizza and fries
Location Insights
Area: Busy mixed-use corridor with locals, commuters, and students; practical everyday dining over destination glam.
Safety: Generally active with steady foot traffic; typical urban edges but no broad safety alarms in reviews.
Nearby: Near Kosciuszko St J train; surrounded by bodegas, salons, small eateries, and residential blocks.
BushwickBushwick is known for its dynamic arts scene and rapidly evolving dining landscape, featuring a mix of trendy cafes, artisanal eateries, and traditional local spots. The area attracts a diverse crowd interested in innovative cuisine and cultural experiences, while still retaining a gritty, authentic Brooklyn vibe.
East BushwickEast Bushwick is a sub-area characterized by industrial spaces converted into art studios and hip dining venues, alongside longstanding residential blocks. It offers an eclectic mix of casual and upscale dining options, reflecting the neighborhood's ongoing gentrification and cultural diversity.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–22:00
Tuesday11:00–22:00
Wednesday11:00–22:00
Thursday11:00–22:00
Friday11:00–22:00
Saturday11:00–22:00
Sunday11:00–22:00
Available: Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →