Seemor
CaravaggioB+Worth Trying
23 E 74th St, New York, NY 10021
· Italian restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (365 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Elegant Upper East Side Italian with polished hospitality and refined classics; superb pastas and desserts, premium prices, and occasional service inconsistencies.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Caravaggio delivers exceptional food quality with refined Italian cooking—silky pastas, pristine seafood, and polished desserts—paired with gracious, attentive service in a warm, artfully designed room. However, inconsistent execution across visits—including occasional stockouts, dry dishes, and isolated safety concerns—prevents the higher reliability expected of grade A dining. Premium pricing and pricey wines reflect neighborhood positioning but limit value perception for some diners.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and elegant with contemporary art and a hush that makes conversation easy. Service often reads as gracious and attentive, with staff guiding specials and wine. One diner summed it up: "From start to finish, every detail felt considered." On rough nights, a firm host stance or stockouts can jar the mood. In the kitchen, the cooking leans classic Italian refined rather than showy—silky house pastas, pristine seafood, and polished desserts. Think capellini with crab and shrimp, branzino with seasonal vegetables, and a craveable profiterole finish. Portions skew elegant over hearty, and pricing reflects premium ingredients and the neighborhood. Families do fine here thanks to approachable pastas, simple seafood, and a calm room. There is no explicit kids menu, but buttered noodles or plain tomato sauces are easy fits. Budget accordingly; it is a special-occasion spend for most families.
At a Glance
- Sophisticated Italian with standout pastas and desserts
- Quiet, conversation-friendly dining room
- Knowledgeable service and strong specials program
- Premium pricing and pricey wines by the glass
- Occasional off nights with unavailable items or seating rigidity
What Sets It Apart
- art_collection_ambiance
- refined_pasta_program
- upper_east_side_elegance
What People Love
- Elegant, calm room that feels special
- Silky, flavorful pasta and seafood
- Thoughtful pacing and attentive service
- Memorable desserts like profiteroles and Rocher
Points of Concern
- Pricing is genuinely expensive ($50-65 mains; pasta $30-40; wines by glass ~$30+)
- A few reports of rude or inflexible hosting on busy nights
- Isolated food safety and cleanliness complaints outside patio; not a consistent pattern
- Review patterns show natural variation with some extreme negatives; overall authenticity solid
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$95-135 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair seafood starters (octopus or calamari) with a lighter pasta, then share one main to manage cost and portions
- Ask for wine recommendations by the glass within a budget to avoid sticker shock
Perfect For
- Pre- or post-Met museum dinner
- Romantic date night where conversation matters
- Celebrations that call for polished service
- Business dinners with refined ambiance
Location Insights
Area: Upscale Upper East Side block near museums and luxury retail; suits refined dining and special occasions.
Safety: Generally very safe, well-lit, high foot traffic in evenings near Madison/Fifth corridors.
Nearby: Near The Met and Madison Ave boutiques; residential towers and galleries shape elegant crowd.
Lenox HillLenox Hill offers a sophisticated dining scene with a mix of classic New York eateries, upscale restaurants, and casual cafes. The area is known for its safe, polished environment attracting well-heeled locals and visitors seeking quality dining experiences in a relaxed yet elegant setting.
nullnull
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–22:00
Tuesday12:00–22:00
Wednesday12:00–22:00
Thursday12:00–22:00
Friday12:00–22:00
Saturday12:00–22:00
Sunday12:00–22:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →