Outstanding East Village slice shop with crisp NY-style pies, a beloved vodka slice, quick counter service, and budget-friendly prices, though occasional burnt bottoms and delivery issues appear.
Cello's Pizzeria delivers solid neighborhood slice shop quality anchored by exceptional food quality—the vodka slice and pepperoni-jalapeno standouts showcase crisp, balanced execution that justifies its East Village reputation. However, inconsistent execution with occasional burnt bottoms and cold delivery prevents a higher grade, while strong location appeal and excellent value make it competitive with respected local favorites rather than a destination establishment.
One caveat: Burnt bottoms or over-reheat appear periodically, especially at busy times