Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Neighborhood pizza hub with thin-crust slices, a broad Italian menu, and casual bar vibe; food is generally good, service can wobble at peak times.
Centro Pizza Bar delivers strong food quality anchored by bright, balanced sauce and crispy thin crust that regulars reliably praise, but inconsistent execution—occasional burnt slices, dry burgers, and delivery delays—prevents grade A territory. The pleasant waterfront-adjacent setting with backyard patio and comfortable seating make it a solid neighborhood destination, though not a citywide draw. Best approached as a dependable local favorite for pizza and pasta rather than a culinary standout.
Centro hums like a neighborhood clubhouse with a slice counter, a tidy bar, and a surprisingly roomy backyard. Regulars rave about the red sauce, calling it bright and balanced, while the room stays casual and inviting. One diner summed it up: "Crisp thin crust, friendly crew, and a patio when the weather cooperates." Expect a crowd on weekends, but service is usually fast and upbeat. The cooking is classic NYC Italian-American at heart, not flashy—think thin-crust pies, Sicilian squares, chicken Marsala, and vodka-sauced pasta. The culinary approach leans comfort-first and familiar (innovation level 3.6): specialty slices like spinach dip add fun without going full fusion. Most people come for pizza; burgers and some mains draw mixed notes, so steer toward pies, fried calamari, and pastas for the strongest hit rate. Families do well here. There is a real kids menu (pasta with butter, chicken fingers, hamburger and fries), plus simple pizzas and garlic knots. Portions are friendly, prices fair for LIC, and the menu covers vegetarians and even a gluten-free 12 inch pie. If your child is adventurous, explore toppings; if not, stick to plain or pepperoni and you will be fine.
Area: Energetic waterfront LIC corridor with apartments, bars, and casual dining; draws locals and hotel guests.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, steady evening foot traffic near Vernon Blvd.
Nearby: Near Gantry Plaza waterfront, hotels like SpringHill, residential towers, and other pizzerias and cafes.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →