Seemor
ClayBMixed Bag
553 Manhattan Ave, New York, NY 10027
· New American restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (533 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Polished New American spot with standout pastas, duck, and a sharp wine list; service can be uneven and a few serious food safety complaints warrant caution.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Clay delivers strong food quality anchored by excellent house-made pastas and duck confit, with a thoughtfully curated wine program that justifies its reputation as a neighborhood gem. However, multiple recent food safety complaints tied to seafood, inconsistent execution across visits, and service variability ranging from gracious to rigid prevent a higher grade. The intimate Harlem setting appeals to locals but doesn't overcome reliability concerns for diners seeking consistent excellence.
Restaurant Summary
Clay reads as a polished Harlem refuge where the room feels warm and intimate and the wine list is carefully curated. Guests talk about thoughtful pacing, anniversaries remembered, and a burger that anchors many return visits. One diner summed it up: "They made us feel celebrated." Note that a handful of diners reported some review authenticity concerns suggesting certain reviews may be solicited or influenced. In the kitchen, the style leans New American with creative contemporary touches: sesame-kissed tartare, miso creme on beets, and house-made pastas like short rib bucatini that deliver real depth. Duck confit lands tender and balanced, while the crab calamarata divides opinion—some adore its brightness, others find it harsh. Service warmth swings from gracious hospitality to policy rigidity, so experiences can vary. For families, evidence is mixed. There is a solid burger and fries and simpler sides like cauliflower with honey that kids may accept, but no kids menu and slower pacing can frustrate. Several reports describe staff inflexibility and long waits with toddlers; families with young children should consider earlier reservations or choose elsewhere.
At a Glance
- House-made pastas and duck confit consistently delight
- Exceptional, curated wine list with savvy pairings
- Service inconsistency and rigid policies reported
- Small portions for some mains versus price
- Multiple recent food safety complaints about seafood dishes
What Sets It Apart
- curated_wine_program
- house_made_pastas
- neighborhood_date_spot_ambience
What People Love
- That melt-in-your-mouth duck leg
- Short rib bucatini with deep, savory sauce
- Burger and hand-cut fries as a reliable favorite
- A wine list that feels handpicked, not oversized
Points of Concern
- Crab calamarata polarizes; some find it overly acidic
- Several diners reported illness after seafood; proceed cautiously
- Policy rigidity: pressured to order full courses, limited substitutions
- Service swings from warmly attentive to curt or dismissive on bad nights
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$70-95 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Lean toward pastas ($26-34) and duck ($46) for best value-to-pleasure ratio
- Add a side (cauliflower or mushrooms, $14) if ordering fish due to portion size
- Finish with panna cotta or budino ($15) for balanced sweetness
Perfect For
- A cozy date with pasta and a great bottle
- Celebrating a low-key birthday or anniversary
- Wine-focused dinners with seasonal small plates
- Neighborhood nights when you want chef-driven comfort
Location Insights
Area: Residential Harlem block with relaxed neighborhood vibe; attracts date nights and small celebrations.
Safety: Generally safe with steady foot traffic; isolated complaints about basement odor suggest maintenance vigilance needed.
Nearby: Near Harlem restaurant corridors, bars, and brownstones; draws locals and destination diners.
HarlemHarlem is known for its deep African American cultural heritage and a growing food scene that blends traditional soul food with modern culinary trends. The neighborhood has a lively social atmosphere with a mix of historic venues, new restaurants, and community-focused eateries, attracting both locals and visitors.
Hamilton HeightsHamilton Heights is a quieter, more residential part of Harlem with historic brownstones and a growing number of cafes and casual dining spots. It offers a more relaxed dining environment compared to central Harlem, appealing to neighborhood residents and college students.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday17:00–21:00
Tuesday17:00–21:00
Wednesday17:00–21:00
Thursday17:00–21:00
Friday17:00–21:30
Saturday17:00–21:30
Sunday17:00–21:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →