Seemor
$1.50 Fresh PizzaBWorth Trying
71 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003
· Pizza restaurant, Fast food restaurant, Pizza delivery
· 4.5/5 Google (690 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Ultra-cheap grab-and-go slices that deliver solid flavor for the price, best for quick bites not sit-down meals.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
$1.50 Fresh Pizza delivers reliable value-focused execution with solid food quality and exceptional speed that define its appeal. Consistent fresh pies and strong repeat customer loyalty confirm its standing as a respected East Village institution. However, severe space constraints with no seating, occasional service friction, and mixed recent quality signals prevent higher grades—this is grab-and-go efficiency, not destination dining.
Restaurant Summary
A classic East Village slice window where the vibe is fast and scrappy, the pies move quickly, and the price tag still makes people grin. Expect counter-only service, a tiny space, and hot slices. One regular summed it up: "cheap, hot, and hits the spot". Come for the value, not the decor; think grab-and-go efficiency over comfort. The cooking is straightforward NY-style—thin crust, basic toppings, and steady turnover. The culinary approach leans classic and no-frills: familiar flavors, a good reheat when needed, and premium toppings if you want more heft. Ideal for people who prize speed and value over variety or presentation. For families, the food is inherently kid-friendly—plain cheese slices and mild pepperoni are easy wins. The catch is the space: it is extremely tight with no tables, so strollers and lingering do not mix. If you are nearby, this is a quick, low-cost bite; for a sit-down meal with kids, choose a spot with actual seating.
At a Glance
- Outstanding value with $1.50 cheese slices and low-cost specials
- Fast service and frequent fresh pies
- No seating and very tight space
- Occasional reports of rudeness or overcharging
- Quality can feel bland or doughy to some
What Sets It Apart
- ultra_low_price_slices
- fast_late_night_service
What People Love
- Paying pocket change and feeling satisfied
- Hot slices with quick turnover
- Simple, classic NY-style bite
- Speedy service when pies are flowing
Points of Concern
- No tables and tiny interior make lingering uncomfortable
- A few complaints about staff attitude or change handling
- Some diners find slices under-seasoned or dough not crisp enough
- Occasional 3-5 minute waits when a fresh pie is baking
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter Only
Average Cost$4.00-$8.50 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Value first: two-slice-and-drink special at $4 is the sweet spot
- For more flavor, choose Buffalo Chicken or BBQ Chicken slices at $3
- Whole cheese pie at $12 is the best group value if you can carry out
Perfect For
- Late-night post-bar snack
- Budget-friendly quick lunch
- Students on the go
- Pizza crawl stop
Location Insights
Area: Lively East Village strip with students, late-night crowds, and quick-bite spots.
Safety: Busy, well-traveled at most hours; typical urban vigilance advised late night.
Nearby: Near bars, music venues, NYU, and other affordable eateries; strong foot traffic.
East VillageThe dining scene in East Village is diverse and dynamic, featuring everything from casual eateries and ethnic food spots to trendy bars and upscale restaurants. The social atmosphere is lively and youthful, with a strong emphasis on creativity and community, making it a hotspot for foodies and nightlife enthusiasts alike.
Alphabet CityAlphabet City, part of the East Village, is known for its bohemian vibe and emerging culinary scene, with many innovative restaurants and bars attracting a crowd interested in unique dining experiences and a laid-back atmosphere.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday09:30–05:00
Tuesday09:30–05:00
Wednesday09:30–05:00
Thursday09:30–05:00
Friday09:30–05:00
Saturday09:30–05:00
Sunday09:30–04:30
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →