Seemor

Club A SteakhouseB+Worth Trying

Name: Club A Steakhouse
Address: 240 E 58th St, New York, NY 10022, New York, United States
Rating: 4.8

240 E 58th St, New York, NY 10022 · Steak house · 4.8/5 Google (3582 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery

Classic NYC steakhouse with warm, celebratory hospitality, excellent porterhouse, live jazz, and frequent complimentary desserts, but service pace and Groupon experiences vary; best on non-peak nights.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Club A Steakhouse delivers reliable steakhouse excellence with exceptional porterhouse and prime cuts and warm, attentive hospitality that create genuine celebratory moments. However, inconsistent execution on peak nights and service delays during busy periods prevent it from reaching grade A territory. The classic old-school atmosphere with live jazz appeals to traditionalists seeking prime ingredients over innovation, making it a solid neighborhood favorite rather than a destination standout.

Restaurant Summary

The room feels warm and bustling, with red walls, family photos, and live jazz setting an old-school New York scene. Staff are often warm and welcoming, and more than a few diners mention the owner stopping by with a signed card. One guest captured the mood: "It felt like more than dinner, it was an experience." The menu is classic steakhouse, leaning elevated traditional rather than experimental. Porterhouse and bone-in rib eye draw raves, while sides like creamed spinach and whipped potatoes complete the picture. This suits diners who want prime ingredients over theatrics, though on peak nights a few report overcooked steaks or sluggish pacing. Families do well here: teens and kids shared steaks and loved the sides, and there is a burger and simple seafood for less adventurous eaters. There is no formal kids menu, but plenty of accessible choices like fries, mashed potatoes, and mac and cheese; expect premium pricing for a celebratory outing.

At a Glance

Porterhouse and prime cuts consistently impress
Genuine hospitality with owner interactions and celebratory touches
Live jazz adds classic NYC atmosphere
Service pace and seating delays during peak hours
Promo/Groupon experiences are mixed with stricter menu rules

What Sets It Apart

owner_personal_touch
live_jazz_ambience
printed_celebration_photo

What People Love

Old-school charm with live music
Perfectly cooked porterhouse explained by staff
Complimentary celebration desserts and printed photo
Owner greeting that feels personal

Points of Concern

Peak-time waits even with reservations; slower refills and bar delays
Occasional overcooked or underseasoned steaks on busy nights
Coupon and restaurant week menus are limited and can disappoint value-seekers
Pricing is premium with steaks $65+ and sides à la carte

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$95-135 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Choose porterhouse if sharing; pair with creamed spinach and potato puree
Seafood fans: Chilean sea bass $46 offers a lighter, luxe alternative
Start with fried calamari $20 or crab cake $27 if you prefer non-smoky openers

Perfect For

A classic NYC steak night with jazz
Anniversaries and birthdays
Impressing out-of-town guests
Family celebrations with shareable steaks

Location Insights

Area: Upmarket Midtown East corridor serving office workers, residents, and destination diners seeking classic NYC experiences.

Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked avenues; typical Midtown vigilance needed at night but comfortable.

Nearby: Near office towers, hotels, and shopping along 57th/59th; convenient for celebrations and pre-show dinners.

Turtle BayTurtle Bay offers a mix of upscale dining options, casual eateries, and classic New York delis catering to office workers and residents alike. The area is characterized by a professional daytime crowd with a growing residential community, providing a balanced social atmosphere that is both lively and approachable.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday Tuesday17:00–21:30 Wednesday17:00–21:30 Thursday17:00–21:30 Friday17:00–21:30 Saturday17:00–21:30 Sunday17:00–21:30

Available: Reservations, Delivery

View full analysis on Seemor →