Classic Irish pub near Times Square with solid comfort food, big beer list, and lively multi-level space, but service inconsistency and auto-gratuity reports mean expectations should be managed.
Connolly's delivers reliable pub comfort in a convenient Midtown location, with solid food quality anchored by frequently praised fish & chips and hearty Irish staples. However, inconsistent execution and notably polarized service experiences—ranging from welcoming to rushed and curt—prevent a higher grade. The rooftop and central pre-theater positioning add appeal, but this remains a casual neighborhood refuge rather than a destination, best suited for diners seeking familiar comfort over culinary distinction.
One caveat: Service can be rushed or curt during busy periods; several reports of rude interactions