Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Classic Irish pub near Times Square with solid comfort food, big beer list, and lively multi-level space, but service inconsistency and auto-gratuity reports mean expectations should be managed.
Connolly's delivers reliable pub comfort in a convenient Midtown location, with solid food quality anchored by frequently praised fish & chips and hearty Irish staples. However, inconsistent execution and notably polarized service experiences—ranging from welcoming to rushed and curt—prevent a higher grade. The rooftop and central pre-theater positioning add appeal, but this remains a casual neighborhood refuge rather than a destination, best suited for diners seeking familiar comfort over culinary distinction.
Just off the Broadway rush, Connolly's feels like a classic Midtown refuge with warm Irish pub vibes: booths, pints, and a rooftop that surprises first-timers. One guest noted, "Staff welcomed us back and remembered our order," while another found service rushed and curt. The crowd tilts tourist and pre-theater, so expect a lively scene over hushed dining. The cooking leans hearty and familiar, not flashy: fish and chips, shepherd’s pie, burgers, and a steak or two. The culinary approach is classic comfort: straightforward pub fare done well when the kitchen is on form, with occasional misses like overdone sausages or heavy batter. It suits diners craving reliable comfort food and a strong beer list more than culinary adventure. Families fit in fine here thanks to kid-friendly staples like chicken tenders, burgers, fries, and breakfast plates. Portions are generous and the vibe is casual; there is no dedicated kids menu noted, but the menu has plenty children will eat. If a child is picky, stick to burgers, fries, tenders, or the margherita flatbread.
Area: Steps from Times Square; tourist-heavy, theater crowds, after-work drinks; lively and convenient.
Safety: High foot traffic, well-lit, busy late; typical Midtown vigilance advised.
Nearby: Near Broadway theaters, hotels, offices; multi-level bar with rooftop noted in reviews.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →