Crowded East Village slice shop turning out crisp, foldable NY-style pies with creative options like the double stacked pizza; great in person, spotty for delivery, and pricier-than-average slices.
East Village Pizza delivers solid neighborhood pizza with crisp, well-balanced slices and quick, friendly counter service that justify its reputation as a local favorite. However, inconsistent delivery quality and occasional cold slices prevent a higher grade, while cramped seating and limited space constrain the overall experience. The Instagram-famous double stacked pizza and fair pricing make it worth a visit for hot, in-person consumption.
One caveat: Delivery orders reported as cold or old; better to eat in or pick up hot