Seemor
East Village PizzaBWorth Trying
145 1st Ave, New York, NY 10003
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (2149 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Crowded East Village slice shop turning out crisp, foldable NY-style pies with creative options like the double stacked pizza; great in person, spotty for delivery, and pricier-than-average slices.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
East Village Pizza delivers solid neighborhood pizza with crisp, well-balanced slices and quick, friendly counter service that justify its reputation as a local favorite. However, inconsistent delivery quality and occasional cold slices prevent a higher grade, while cramped seating and limited space constrain the overall experience. The Instagram-famous double stacked pizza and fair pricing make it worth a visit for hot, in-person consumption.
Restaurant Summary
A classic East Village corner slice shop with crisp, foldable slices and a steady stream of late-night foot traffic. Service is quick at the counter, and the vibe is all about the hot pie in hand. As one traveler put it, "That first NYC fold with the shop behind me felt perfect." Social buzz fuels lines, especially for the Instagram-famous double stacked pizza. The cooking leans traditional New York with elevated comfort touches: thin, crackly undercarriage, balanced sauce-cheese, and hearty options like baked ziti and white pies. Innovation level feels like elevated traditional, not chef-y theatrics; the double stacked is indulgent fun best eaten hot. Value is fair for the neighborhood, though slices run above $6 and delivery consistency lags behind counter service. Families do well here thanks to cheese and pepperoni staples, simple sides, and quick service. The menu includes veggie choices and a gluten-free 12 inch base (not celiac-safe). Seating is scarce, so plan a quick bite at the ledge or take pies to-go if wrangling kids.
At a Glance
- Crisp, foldable NY-style slices with balanced sauce and cheese
- Fun specialty double stacked pizza when eaten hot
- Delivery quality often arrives cold or over-reheated
- Limited seating; can feel cramped during rush
- Slices priced $6+ may feel high if expecting dollar-slice pricing
What Sets It Apart
- double_stacked_pizza_specialty
- crisp_foldable_crust
- late-night_slice_energy
What People Love
- That no-flop crispy undercarriage
- Hearty specialty pies like the double stacked
- Fast, friendly counter service
- Reliable pepperoni and white slices
Points of Concern
- Delivery orders reported as cold or old; better to eat in or pick up hot
- Some find prices high for slices compared to expectations
- Cheesy garlic knots cause waits; flavor can be overpowering for some
- Occasional complaints about wrong orders or refund difficulty
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$14-$22 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For value, split an 18 inch cheese ($25) among 3-4; add a topping (+$4) if needed
- Gluten-free diners choose 12 inch GF margherita ($24.99), but avoid if celiac due to cross-contact warning
Perfect For
- Quick solo slice between bar hops
- Late-night cravings after a show
- Casual group grab-and-go before a park hang
- Tourists seeking a classic NY fold
Location Insights
Area: Lively East Village corner with late-night foot traffic, students and creatives; heavy casual dining scene.
Safety: Generally safe, busy corridors with good visibility; typical urban grit and occasional crowding.
Nearby: Near bars, cafes, and indie shops; close to 1st Avenue transit; strong takeaway demand.
East VillageThe East Village dining scene is characterized by a wide variety of casual eateries, trendy cafes, and ethnic restaurants, reflecting the neighborhood's diverse population. It is a lively area with a mix of bohemian charm and modern urban energy, attracting a crowd that values creativity and authenticity in their dining experiences.
Alphabet CityAlphabet City, part of the East Village, is known for its edgy vibe, with numerous bars, music venues, and innovative restaurants. It has a slightly grittier feel compared to the rest of East Village, appealing to those seeking a more underground and alternative social scene.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–03:00
Tuesday11:00–03:00
Wednesday11:00–03:00
Thursday11:00–03:00
Friday11:00–04:30
Saturday11:00–04:30
Sunday11:00–03:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →