Cozy UWS kosher cafe with flavorful Israeli/Mediterranean breakfasts and fish/veg menu; lively vibe, fair prices, occasional slow or uneven service.
Effy's Cafe delivers solid neighborhood dining with above-average food quality anchored by flavorful shakshuka, hummus, and fresh Israeli-Mediterranean fare at reasonable UWS prices. However, quality variation and occasional service lapses during busy periods—including wait times and order accuracy issues—prevent the grade from climbing higher. Best experienced slightly off-peak, where the warm, cozy atmosphere and friendly staff shine without the operational strain.
One caveat: Peak-hour waits of 25-45 minutes reported by several diners