Neighborhood kosher-Mediterranean cafe with fresh, veggie-leaning plates and friendly vibes; expect occasional slow service but solid value for the Upper East Side.
Effy's Cafe on York delivers reliable neighborhood brunch quality through solid food quality anchored in fresh, flavorful Israeli-Mediterranean cooking and strong regular customer loyalty. However, inconsistent execution on items like fries and occasional service slowdowns during peak hours prevent a higher grade. The cozy Yorkville setting and fair pricing make it a worthwhile local favorite, though it lacks the distinction or consistency to compete with the area's premier brunch destinations.
One caveat: Peak-hour waits and delayed orders are reported by several diners