Seemor
Effy's Cafe on YorkB+Worth Trying
1688 York Ave, New York, NY 10128
· Kosher restaurant, Breakfast restaurant, Brunch restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (197 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Neighborhood kosher-Mediterranean cafe with fresh, veggie-leaning plates and friendly vibes; expect occasional slow service but solid value for the Upper East Side.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Effy's Cafe on York delivers reliable neighborhood brunch quality through solid food quality anchored in fresh, flavorful Israeli-Mediterranean cooking and strong regular customer loyalty. However, inconsistent execution on items like fries and occasional service slowdowns during peak hours prevent a higher grade. The cozy Yorkville setting and fair pricing make it a worthwhile local favorite, though it lacks the distinction or consistency to compete with the area's premier brunch destinations.
Restaurant Summary
A cozy Yorkville spot with neighborhood charm, Effy’s buzzes at brunch while staying relaxed enough for solo coffee or a quick bite. Diners praise the fresh, veggie-forward plates and friendly servers, even if service slows during peak hours. One regular put it simply: "It feels like my local—warm, fresh, and easy." Cooking leans Israeli-Mediterranean comfort—think shakshuka and falafel, salmon plates, and lots of greens—more market-driven than flashy. Most dishes are flavorful and satisfying; a few items read mild if you want heavy spice. It suits diners seeking fresh, kosher-friendly brunch without fine-dining formality. For families, this is quite workable: kids can latch onto pancakes or waffles, grilled cheese, fries, or simple omelets. Portions are sensible, prices fair for the area, and staff generally accommodating, though weekend waits are common. If your crew needs classic comfort over heat and herbs, skim the kid-friendly side before ordering.
At a Glance
- Fresh, flavorful Israeli-leaning brunch with many vegetarian and vegan options
- Good value for Upper East Side, especially on sandwiches and omelets
- Service can slow at peak times; occasional curt interactions reported
- Some inconsistency in fries/seasoning and a few smaller portions
- Family-friendly menu with pancakes, waffles, and grilled cheese
What Sets It Apart
- Kosher dairy brunch focus
- Broad vegetarian and vegan options
- All-day breakfast menu
What People Love
- Neighborhood feel with warm staff
- Fresh fish and crisp fries
- Falafel platters and hearty salads
- All-day breakfast comfort classics
Points of Concern
- Peak-hour waits and delayed orders are reported by several diners
- A few dishes land on the mild side; seasoning varies
- Isolated complaints about smaller portions or substitutions without notice
- One food safety allegation without corroboration; majority report clean and fine
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$28-42 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For kids: pancakes, waffles, grilled cheese
- For vegans: falafel wrap, vegan shawarma, hummus/babaganoush starters
- For fish lovers: salmon burger or roasted salmon with greens
Perfect For
- Casual weekend brunch after Asphalt Green
- Weekday breakfast with coffee and a light plate
- Vegetarian/vegan-friendly group outing
- Solo bite with people-watching on York Ave
Location Insights
Area: Residential Yorkville strip near East River; relaxed, local crowd with families and dog walkers.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked by day and evening; typical UES safety profile.
Nearby: Close to Asphalt Green and Gracie Mansion; buses on York Ave; Q/4/5/6 reachable via crosstown walk.
YorkvilleYorkville offers a quieter, more residential feel compared to the rest of the Upper East Side, with a variety of casual and upscale dining options. The dining scene includes traditional American fare, ethnic eateries, and modern bistros, catering to both families and professionals. The neighborhood is safe, accessible, and known for its community-oriented atmosphere.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday08:00–21:00
Tuesday08:00–21:00
Wednesday08:00–21:00
Thursday08:00–21:00
Friday08:00–21:00
Saturday08:00–21:00
Sunday08:00–21:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →