Stylish Aegean/Turkish spot with standout brunch and personable service, creative cocktails, small portions, and confusing pricing on shared breakfast; great vibe but value feels mixed.
Foursome Bar and Restaurant delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by standout Turkish brunch and creative cocktails, paired with warm, attentive service and charming West Village ambiance. However, inconsistent execution on portions and occasional dish quality prevents grade A territory, while modest plate sizes relative to pricing temper the overall value proposition for a neighborhood favorite.
The room feels warm and bustling, all patterned tile and curated touches that make brunch linger into another round of cocktails. Staff check in often and owners greet tables; one diner noted, "we felt like regulars on our first visit." However, there are some review authenticity concerns suggesting certain reviews may be solicited or influenced. Cooking leans Turkish Aegean with a modern, produce-driven sensibility: simit with eggs, juicy meatballs, salads bright with fruit and herbs, plus playful ideas like pishi tacos. Most plates land with vibrant flavors, though a few misses appear (a dry salmon here, a so-so taco there). Portions run modest, and the shared Turkish breakfast pricing needs clearer framing. Families fare well thanks to friendly service and accessible dishes: pancakes, noodles with cheese, fries, burgers. While there is no explicit kids menu on the current list, the pancakes, French toast, and simple bowls are kid-ready. Expect New York pricing and plan to add a side if your crew has big appetites.
Area vibe: Quaint, upscale West Village block popular with locals and visitors; bistro-lined streets and boutique retail.
Safety: Well-lit, high foot traffic, generally safe even late; typical Manhattan street activity.
What's nearby: Near Smalls Jazz Club, boutique shops, brownstones; destination for drinks and brunch hopping.
Go for the Mom's Meatballs or the Manhattan Burger, and add a pancake or truffle fries as a side.
Portions are on the small side for the price, parking is nearly impossible, and there's a reported $20 per-person cancellation fee.