Seemor
GoodFellas Pizzeria of L.I.C.BWorth Trying
25-19 40th Ave, Long Island City, NY 11101
· Pizza restaurant, Fast food restaurant, Delivery Restaurant
· 4.7/5 Google (1143 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Solid, budget-friendly NYC slice window with standout margherita and crispy crust; mostly takeout with a few sidewalk tables and some inconsistency on reheating and service tone.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
GoodFellas Pizzeria delivers reliable neighborhood pizza with strong food quality—particularly praised margherita and crisp-chewy crust—paired with quick, friendly counter service. However, inconsistent execution with occasional cold or old slices and minimal seating prevent a higher grade. For budget-conscious diners seeking fast, quality pizza in LIC, it's a solid choice; just manage expectations around the grab-and-go format.
Restaurant Summary
A classic LIC slice window with quick, friendly counter service and a small cluster of sidewalk tables. Expect a steady hum of city life and slices served on paper plates. One diner put it simply: "The crust had great chew and the pie came out fast." However, the setup is grab-and-go and a few reviews mention cold or older slices when timing is off. The cooking leans traditional New York slice shop: cheese, margherita, Sicilian, and meat lovers, with occasional crowd-pleasers like chicken bacon ranch. The culinary approach is classic comfort rather than showy; the margherita draws the most praise for balance and crispness. Value is strong for the neighborhood, and pies in the $20–$32 range make it easy to feed a group without fuss. For families, it is naturally kid-friendly thanks to simple cheese and pepperoni slices, garlic knots, and straightforward flavors. There is no indoor dining or kids menu, so plan on quick bites at the outdoor tables or take it to-go; the setup works best in fair weather.
At a Glance
- Standout margherita and crisp-chewy crust
- Budget-friendly pricing with cash discounts
- Fast, efficient counter service
- No indoor seating; limited outdoor tables only
- Inconsistent reheating/holding leads to occasional cold or old slices
What Sets It Apart
- street_side_window_service
- cash_discount_pricing
- standout_margherita_slice
- reliable_quick_turnaround
What People Love
- That just-right crust with good undercarriage
- Margherita slice that feels balanced and bright
- Speedy service at the walk-up window
- Prices that feel fair for LIC
Points of Concern
- Occasional cold or older slices when rush subsides
- Reports of curt service and window shut mid-order from a minority of diners
- No indoor seating; weather limits comfort
- Review patterns show signs of typical counter-service variability, not manipulation
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$12-$20 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose margherita or Sicilian if you like a crisp base
- For value, the 2 cheese and soda combo ($8.25) is hard to beat
- Order whole pies for consistent heat and freshness
Perfect For
- Grabbing a quick slice between errands
- Casual budget dinner with a pie to-go
- Solo snack after work or school
- Low-fuss lunch near LIC offices or hotels
Location Insights
Area: Mixed-use LIC block with schools and small businesses; weekday foot traffic and commuter flow.
Safety: Generally safe, active streets; standard urban nuisances like traffic and noise.
Nearby: Near schools, offices, hotels, and bike routes; convenient for quick meals and grab-and-go.
Long Island CityThe dining scene in Long Island City is diverse, featuring trendy cafes, upscale restaurants, and casual eateries that cater to a mix of locals and commuters. The area has a vibrant social atmosphere with a blend of industrial charm and modern urban living, attracting a crowd interested in innovative cuisine and waterfront views.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Tuesday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Wednesday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Thursday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Friday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Saturday
Sunday
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →