Seemor
Queens › Long Island City › GoodFellas Pizzeria of L.I.C.
GoodFellas Pizzeria of L.I.C.B
25-19 40th Ave, Long Island City, NY 11101
· Pizza restaurant, Fast food restaurant, Delivery Restaurant
· Long Island City
Solid, budget-friendly NYC slice window with standout margherita and crispy crust; mostly takeout with a few sidewalk tables and some inconsistency on reheating and service tone.
The verdict
GoodFellas Pizzeria delivers reliable neighborhood pizza with strong food quality—particularly praised margherita and crisp-chewy crust—paired with quick, friendly counter service. However, inconsistent execution with occasional cold or old slices and minimal seating prevent a higher grade. For budget-conscious diners seeking fast, quality pizza in LIC, it's a solid choice; just manage expectations around the grab-and-go format.
One caveat: Occasional cold or older slices when rush subsides
What to order
- Margherita slice
- Good Fella pie/slice
- Chicken Bacon Ranch slice
What diners say
- That just-right crust with good undercarriage
- Margherita slice that feels balanced and bright
- Speedy service at the walk-up window
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Tuesday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Wednesday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Thursday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Friday11:00–16:00, 17:00–21:00
Saturday
Sunday
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →