Delivery · Takeout
A lively Irish pub with standout Guinness, crowd-pleasing snacks, and loud, packed vibes; great for drinks and casual bites, less ideal for quiet conversation or cocktail value seekers.
Grace's delivers solid neighborhood pub quality anchored by strong food execution—particularly wings, fries, and Irish staples—and a legendary Guinness pour that draws loyal repeat visitors. However, cramped seating and narrow walkways combined with inconsistent service during busy periods prevent grade A-grade performance. Best experienced during quieter hours or as a casual drinks destination rather than a full dining destination.
The room feels warm and bustling, a narrow pub that swells into a back space where crowds chatter over pints. Reviewers rave about the pour—one called it the best they have had outside Ireland—while snacks like wings and fries keep the table happy. A guest summed up the vibe: "Packed but friendly, a spot I try to hit every NYC trip." Do expect it to get loud and lively, especially on busy nights. In the kitchen it is classic Irish pub fare with Irish-inspired comforts like chicken curry and a proper beef-and-Guinness stew. Cooking is reliable rather than showy; the hits are wings, fries, fish sandwich, and a solid burger. Cocktails draw mixed notes—some find pours small for the price—so the best play is beer, particularly the Guinness. This suits drink-led hangs, after-work meetups, and casual dates that prefer character over polish. Families can make it work early or off-peak. Kids tend to like fries, wings, and grilled cheese, and one parent specifically recommended it after a smooth visit. The space tightens when busy and noise can spike, so earlier hours are the safer bet if you are toting younger diners.
Area: Trendy West Village/Chelsea edge with heavy nightlife foot traffic; attracts bar-hoppers and after-work crowds.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, busy corridors; occasional late-night crowding typical of the corridor.
Nearby: Near multiple subway lines and PATH access; surrounded by bars, small restaurants, and boutique retail.
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →