Neighborhood Mexican spot with standout guacamole, great value tacos and burritos, friendly service, and occasional inconsistency at busy times.
I Love Guacamole delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by standout guacamole and salsas, paired with attentive, welcoming service and notably fast execution. Occasional blandness and dry preparations prevent grade A territory, while the cozy neighborhood setting offers comfort without destination appeal. Excellent value and loyal repeat business confirm this is a dependable neighborhood favorite worth visiting.
This cozy South Slope spot feels warm and welcoming from the minute you sit down. Servers are often described as attentive and kind, and plates land quickly. One guest summed it up: "Guacamole was a standout and the tacos were packed with flavor." Expect a neighborhood crowd and a relaxed pace that builds to lively at dinner. The cooking leans traditional and generous rather than showy—think classic tacos and pozole, occasional goat in red sauce, and burritos that satisfy without breaking the bank. Salsas matter here, and specials are worth asking about. It is a dependable place for familiar Mexican comforts with a few regional flourishes. Families do well: there are kid-friendly staples like quesadillas, tacos, rice and beans, plus mild salsas. The menu includes vegetarian and some vegan options like nopal and chips with guacamole, so mixed-diet tables can find something without stress.
Area vibe: Residential-boutique stretch of Fifth Ave with local shops and bars; relaxed neighborhood vibe.
Safety: Generally safe, well-traveled corridor with steady evening foot traffic.
What's nearby: Near Greenwood Cemetery and Prospect Park fringe; mix of families and young professionals.
Guacamole is a must, then pick tacos by the piece or a filling burrito like the birria or shrimp.
Casual, kid-friendly spot with outdoor seating and usually short waits, but parking is tight and some dishes can be inconsistent.
Cozy, local-feeling place with warm service and unpretentious decor that welcomes families and regulars.