Stylish Aussie-inspired spot with creative small plates, strong cocktails, and warm service; pricing is premium but matches quality, though a few service misses suggest new-opening growing pains.
Isla & Co. delivers solid A-grade performance through exceptional food quality with standout lamb and cod curry, paired with outstanding design appeal that makes the Lower East Side location feel warm and polished. Attentive service and knowledgeable staff elevate the experience, though moderate uncertainty around review authenticity and consistency still settling post-opening prevents a higher grade.
One caveat: Pricing is premium, especially steaks and larger mains