Casual Italian in the Garment District with counter ordering, solid pizzas and simple pastas, but inconsistent execution, crowding, and small portions; good for a quick bite near Times Square if expectations are set.
IT Italian Trattoria delivers occasional highlights—truffle pizza and friendly staff earn genuine praise—but inconsistent execution undermines reliability, with reports of cold pasta, undersauced dishes, and variable service pacing. Tight seating and crowding during rushes, combined with hygiene concerns, prevent a higher grade despite the convenient midtown location. Best suited for quick coffee runs or simple pizza orders rather than full meals.
One caveat: Pasta consistency varies; several reports of cold or bland dishes