Seemor
Joe & Sal's PizzaA-Worth Trying
842 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
· Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Pizza delivery
· 4.7/5 Google (938 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Beloved neighborhood slice shop with standout pies and warm service; excellent for dine-in or pickup but delivery reliability is a recurring weak spot.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Joe & Sal's Pizza earns its A- grade through exceptional food quality—crisp thin crust and balanced Sicilian squares that inspire genuine enthusiasm—paired with strong counter hospitality and authentic neighborhood charm. Reliable execution keeps regulars returning, though delivery delays and modest ambiance prevent grade A territory. A solid neighborhood destination for quality pizza without pretense.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and bustling, a neighborhood slice shop where regulars swap nods with the counter crew and Italian tunes set an easy groove. One diner gushed that the crust was "crisp outside, soft inside," and staff offered condiments without being asked. If you walk in, expect friendly counter service, a renovated space with vintage touches, and a rotating lineup of slices that keeps locals coming back. The cooking leans classic New York with elevated touches: crisp-thin round pies, sturdy Sicilian squares, and signatures like burrata-topped pizzas and a creamy vodka slice. Flavors skew clean and ingredient-driven rather than flashy; think burrata, basil, and good olive oil doing the talking. It is ideal for anyone who values ingredient quality over gimmicks, though purists should note occasional price premiums on specialty slices. For families, the menu is very approachable: plain cheese, pepperoni, Sicilian squares, and pastas like ziti and ravioli are easy wins. There is no formal kids menu, but portions and options suit younger eaters, and seating works for a quick bite. If ordering with children in mind, choose simple pies for consistency and skip delivery during peak times.
At a Glance
- Outstanding crisp-thin crust and flavorful Sicilian/Nonna pies
- Friendly, helpful counter team and inviting neighborhood vibe
- Strong vegetarian and some vegan pizza options
- Delivery frequently delayed or mishandled via third-party apps
- Specialty slices priced higher than basic options
What Sets It Apart
- burrata_forward_specials
- memorable_sicilian_squares
- neighborhood_community_wall
What People Love
- Crispy crust with soft center
- Burrata and vodka slices with bright flavors
- Genuine, kind staff interactions
- Classic Brooklyn slice shop atmosphere
Points of Concern
- Delivery reliability is poor in multiple reports (late, cold, or incorrect orders)
- Phone support can be hard to reach during rush hours
- Space near the door/register gets crowded in peak times
- Specialty slices feel pricey to some compared with basic cheese or dollar-slice alternatives
- Review patterns show natural mix; no manipulation indicators detected
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$16-$28 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For vegetarians: Margherita, Giardiniera, Burrata Pomodoro, Deep Dish Slice with spinach.
- For vegans: Vegan Marinara or Vegan White pies.
- Value play: Whole Classica or Siciliana for groups; add garlic knots.
Perfect For
- Grabbing an excellent slice after work
- Low-key family pizza night
- Group pickup for school or game night
- Visitors chasing classic Brooklyn pizza
Location Insights
Area: Mixed residential and small-business corridor drawing locals, students, and families; casual, lively vibe.
Safety: Generally busy with steady foot traffic; typical urban awareness advised, especially late.
Nearby: Near Prospect Park and Brooklyn Museum zones; schools create after-school rush; transit-rich Franklin Ave corridor.
Crown HeightsCrown Heights offers a dynamic dining scene with a blend of Caribbean, Jewish, and American cuisines, reflecting its diverse community. The neighborhood has seen increased development and gentrification, attracting a mix of traditional residents and newcomers seeking authentic and trendy dining experiences. It maintains a community-oriented atmosphere with local eateries, casual dining spots, and some upscale restaurants.
Franklin Avenue CorridorThe Franklin Avenue Corridor is a lively stretch known for its cultural institutions, local shops, and a variety of eateries that serve Caribbean and soul food alongside newer, eclectic dining options. It acts as a community hub with a friendly, accessible vibe and a mix of old and new influences.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–22:00
Tuesday11:00–22:00
Wednesday11:00–22:00
Thursday11:00–22:00
Friday11:00–23:00
Saturday11:00–23:00
Sunday12:00–22:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →