Polished, lively Italian in the Theater District with fresh house-made pasta and attentive pre-show timing; pricey, crowded, and occasionally uneven apps and bar service.
La Masseria NY delivers solid A-grade performance through exceptional house-made pastas and quality Italian cooking paired with outstanding service attentiveness that expertly times meals around theater schedules. However, tight seating during peak hours and occasional consistency variations in appetizers prevent the higher distinction needed for grade A territory. It's a reliable Theater District destination for classic Italian dining with strong execution in its core strengths.
One caveat: Fritto misto and calamari quality can be inconsistent