Seemor
La Nostra PizzeriaC-Proceed Cautiously
2146 2nd Ave #3207, New York, NY 10029
· Pizza restaurant, Delivery Restaurant, Takeout Restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (416 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Neighborhood slice and red-sauce classics with low prices but recurring service and delivery issues; good if you want inexpensive pies and pasta, risky for time-sensitive orders.
Why it gets a C- for overall quality
La Nostra Pizzeria delivers acceptable pizza when executed well, but inconsistent food quality and temperature issues combined with poor service reliability and delivery delays undermine the experience. While the menu offers budget-friendly comfort classics ideal for families, operational lapses—missed orders, hour-long waits, dismissive interactions—prevent this from being a dependable neighborhood choice despite its traditional appeal.
Restaurant Summary
This East Harlem spot comes off as a classic counter-service slice shop: bright cases, hearty heroes, and pies for takeout or a quick bite. Several diners praise the pizza when it is hot, but others describe long waits and curt replies, with one remarking, "We waited an hour only to learn the order had not been made." Expect no-frills service, a functional space, and a crowd that skews local. The kitchen leans traditional: red-sauce pasta bakes, parm heroes, and New York pies like Grandma and vodka pizza. When fresh, flavors hit that satisfying corner-pizza mark; inconsistency shows up with cold deliveries or items that sat too long. This is comfort-first cooking rather than culinary fireworks, and the prices reflect that. Families do fine here thanks to familiar choices: plain or pepperoni pizza, baked ziti, mozzarella sticks, chicken fingers, and fries. There is no formal kids menu, but the kid-friendly staples are plentiful and fairly priced. For stress-free family nights, consider pickup over delivery to avoid timing surprises.
At a Glance
- Broad, budget-friendly menu of classic pizza and red-sauce dishes
- Kid-friendly staples like mozzarella sticks, pasta, and plain pies
- Delivery delays and missed order notes reported
- Rigid policies on condiments and replacements reduce goodwill
- Inconsistent food temperature on arrival
What Sets It Apart
- very_broad_menu_for_a_slice_shop
- mini_pies_variety
- classic_red_sauce_value
What People Love
- Straightforward NY-style pies when fresh
- Hearty heroes and pasta bakes
- Affordable pricing for large portions
- Wide selection including mini pies and classics
Points of Concern
- Delivery can exceed 60 minutes even for short distances; consider pickup at busy times
- Requests via apps (condiments, spices) sometimes missed
- Replacements and condiments may incur charges and are not always accommodated
- Review patterns show selection bias toward critical experiences; broader rating distribution is more positive
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$22-$35 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For value: Cheese Pizza ($20) with Garlic Knots ($3).
- For a filling meal: Chicken Parm Hero ($11.95-$12.95) plus fries ($5.95).
- For pasta lovers: Baked Ziti ($10.95) or Penne alla Vodka ($13.95).
Perfect For
- A quick neighborhood slice or hero
- Low-cost weeknight takeout
- Feeding a crowd with familiar comfort food
- Families wanting simple pizza-night options
Location Insights
Area: Busy East Harlem corridor with mix of longtime locals and newcomers; practical, everyday dining over destination polish.
Safety: Generally active with steady foot traffic; typical urban caution at late hours.
Nearby: Near residential blocks, small shops, and transit lines; delivery demand appears high.
East HarlemEast Harlem, also known as Spanish Harlem or El Barrio, has a vibrant cultural identity with a growing dining scene that blends traditional Latin American eateries with trendy new restaurants. The area is undergoing gradual gentrification, leading to a mix of old-school neighborhood charm and emerging upscale dining options.
East Harlem WaterfrontThis micro-neighborhood along the East River features newer residential towers with modern amenities, offering scenic views and attracting a more affluent demographic. Dining here includes a mix of casual eateries and upscale restaurants catering to residents and visitors enjoying the waterfront.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–22:00
Tuesday10:00–22:00
Wednesday10:00–22:00
Thursday10:00–22:00
Friday10:00–22:00
Saturday10:00–22:00
Sunday10:00–22:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →