Classic East Harlem slice shop with reliably tasty pies, generous portions, and fair prices, though delivery speed and phone service can be inconsistent.
La Nostra Pizzeria delivers satisfying food quality anchored by excellent cheese and vodka pies, supported by strong multi-decade local loyalty and generous portions at fair prices. However, quality variation in non-pizza items and occasional service inconsistencies—particularly delivery delays—prevent grade A territory. This is reliable neighborhood pizza, not destination dining.
One caveat: Delivery delays and missed items reported by multiple diners; plan extra time or pick up when possible