Seemor
Downtown Manhattan › Financial District › Luke's Lobster FiDi
Luke's Lobster FiDiB+
26 S William St, New York, NY 10004
· Seafood restaurant, American restaurant, Caterer
· Financial District
Premium, fast-casual lobster rolls with excellent freshness, small portions, and occasional service inconsistency; great for a quick seafood fix if you accept FiDi pricing.
Why this grade
Luke's Lobster FiDi delivers exceptional fresh lobster and chowder with quick service, earning solid B+ performance. However, inconsistent counter interactions and cramped seating prevent a higher grade, while occasional quality variation limits reliability. For seafood lovers seeking a fast, premium New England bite in FiDi, it delivers—just expect smaller portions and occasional service friction.
One caveat: Pricing is premium; some feel the portion-to-price ratio is modest
What to order here
- Lobster Roll (warm butter 6oz)
- New England Clam Chowder
- Seafood Roll Flight
What stands out
- Sweet, buttery lobster with generous chunks
- Rich, comforting clam chowder
- Consistent speed for a quick meal
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–19:00
Tuesday11:00–19:00
Wednesday11:00–19:00
Thursday11:00–19:00
Friday11:00–19:00
Saturday11:00–19:00
Sunday11:00–19:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →