Seemor

Mimi's Pizza (Broadway)B+Worth Trying

Name: Mimi's Pizza (Broadway)
Address: 2393 Broadway, New York, NY 10024, New York, United States
Rating: 4.8

2393 Broadway, New York, NY 10024 · Pizza restaurant · 4.8/5 Google (263 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Neighborhood slice shop with crisp NY-style pies, friendly speed, and fair pricing; a go-to for slices with a few consistency blips on cheese and sides.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Mimi's Pizza delivers solid neighborhood pizza through crisp, well-balanced thin crust and quick, friendly counter service that keeps lines moving efficiently. Occasional texture inconsistencies and a cramped, drafty dining room prevent grade A territory, but strong local loyalty and reasonable value make it a reliable Upper West Side choice for casual pizza.

Restaurant Summary

This Upper West Side slice shop hums with quick, friendly service and the smell of fresh pies coming out fast. Reviewers praise the crisp, foldable crust and balanced sauce, with one noting, "they keep everything moving like a well-oiled machine." The room is no-frills and cozy, and it can crowd at peak times, but that buzz reads as neighborhood energy. The cooking leans classic New York—thin, crispy slices, grandma squares, and a few upgrades like burrata and truffled mushrooms. Most come for cheese or cup-and-char pepperoni, while buffalo chicken squares get shout-outs for crunch. It is comfort-first, not showy, and the prices match the vibe: reasonable for the UWS and generous in slice size. Families fit right in thanks to kid-friendly staples like cheese, pepperoni, and plain grandma. There is gluten-free crust for specific needs, plus salads and simple pastas. If your crew eats simply, you will be fine; picky eaters can skip the specialty toppings and stick to the classics.

At a Glance

Crisp NY-style crust with balanced sauce and generous slice size
Friendly, efficient counter service with steady pace even during lines
Strong neighborhood following; many repeat customers
Occasional misses on cheese texture, garlic knots, and eggplant parm
Space can feel tight and drafty in winter near the door

What Sets It Apart

cup_and_char_pepperoni_squares
consistent_crispy_crust
burrata_caprese_slice

What People Love

That nostalgic NY slice crunch
Cup-and-char pepperoni squares
Reasonable prices for big slices
Consistent, friendly counter service
Simple classics done right

Points of Concern

A minority cite rubbery cheese or bland pepperoni on off days
Garlic knots and eggplant parm draw mixed to negative feedback
Crowded at peaks; limited standing room and door drafts in winter
Occasional order errors corrected but cause delays (e.g., gluten-free remake)

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost$16-$24 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Build a classic combo: cheese or pepperoni slice ($3.44-$4.36) plus house salad ($7.95) for value
For hearty eaters, share a Grandma Traditional pie ($23.95) and add wings ($11.00)

Perfect For

Grabbing a fast, satisfying slice between errands
Casual family dinner without breaking the budget
Pre-park or post-museum quick bite
Late-evening slice when you want something reliable

Location Insights

Area: Busy Upper West Side corridor with heavy foot traffic, families, and students; casual, convenience-focused dining.

Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, steady pedestrian flow typical of Broadway on UWS.

Nearby: Near residences, shops, and transit; handy for a quick bite before parks or Riverside drives.

Upper West SideThe Upper West Side offers a diverse dining scene ranging from casual eateries to upscale restaurants, catering to a well-educated and affluent population. The atmosphere is generally relaxed and family-friendly, with a mix of longtime residents and newcomers who appreciate the neighborhood's cultural amenities and accessibility.

Lincoln SquareLincoln Square is a sub-area of the Upper West Side centered around the Lincoln Center for the Performing Arts, attracting visitors attending performances as well as locals enjoying the nearby dining and entertainment options. The dining scene here includes a blend of upscale restaurants and casual spots catering to both arts patrons and neighborhood residents.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday10:00–22:00 Tuesday10:00–22:00 Wednesday10:00–22:00 Thursday10:00–00:00 Friday10:00–00:00 Saturday10:00–00:00 Sunday10:00–22:00

Available: Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →