Seemor
Nick's PizzaA-Worth Trying
1814 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128
· Pizza restaurant, Italian restaurant, Pizza delivery
· 4.4/5 Google (631 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Neighborhood Italian spot with thin-crust pies, generous family-style pastas, and warm service; value is fair to good given portions, but recent price hikes and occasional service hiccups polarize.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Nick's Pizza delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by reliable thin-crust pizza and classic Italian comfort fare, paired with exceptional service attentiveness that makes regulars feel genuinely welcomed. Recent price increases and occasional consistency dips prevent grade A territory, while the pleasant neighborhood setting offers comfortable family dining without destination-level appeal—a reliable neighborhood favorite rather than a culinary standout.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and inviting, with a lively neighborhood hum and staff who seem to genuinely enjoy taking care of people. A guest summed it up: "Service was the friendliest we have had in a while," and several locals say it feels like coming home. Renovations freshened the space without losing its family-run charm. In the kitchen, the approach is classic American-Italian: crisp, char-kissed thin-crust pies, hearty eggplant parm, and big bowls of pasta that satisfy more than they surprise. Specials like arancini or a drizzle of hot honey on pizza add small flourishes, but this is comfort-first cooking best suited for those craving familiar flavors over culinary theater. For families, it is an easy yes. Kids can share a 12 or 16 inch pie, simple pastas like pomodoro, or Parmesan fries. Reviews mention toddlers welcomed and large parties handled smoothly. There is no formal kids menu in the provided data, but the food style is naturally kid-friendly.
At a Glance
- Thin-crust brick-oven pizza with balanced char
- Generous family-style portions and smooth private events
- Friendly, attentive staff with strong regular base
- Noticeable recent price increases and occasional quality dips
- Isolated negative service encounters near closing time
What Sets It Apart
- brick_oven_thin_crust
- generous_family_style_portions
- strong_local_regular_base
- private_room_for_events
What People Love
- Crisp, flavorful thin-crust pies
- Big portions that encourage sharing
- Warm, proactive service that remembers regulars
- Comforting classics like eggplant parm and vodka pasta
- Happy hour deals and relaxed bar vibe
Points of Concern
- Recent price hikes surprised some regulars; value hinges on portion sharing
- A few reports of inconsistent pizza or seasoning on off nights
- Isolated negative interactions when arriving close to closing time
- Review patterns show enthusiastic tones from some users; authenticity overall solid but marketing-like phrasing appears occasionally
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$42-65 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Share a Harvest Salad ($16) and a 16 inch Old Fashioned Pie ($25) for two
- Pair Penne Vodka (Single $23) with a side of roasted potatoes ($10) for a filling, affordable combo
Perfect For
- Casual family dinners with shareable plates
- Neighborhood pizza nights with friends
- Private celebrations in a relaxed setting
- Solo bar bite and happy hour
Location Insights
Area: Busy Upper East Side corridor with mixed residential and casual dining, appealing to locals and visiting families.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked area with good lighting and steady foot traffic.
Nearby: Near residential blocks, retail, and Metropolitan Hospital; convenient for gatherings and events.
YorkvilleYorkville offers a more relaxed and residential dining atmosphere compared to the busier parts of the Upper East Side, with a variety of casual eateries, local bistros, and some upscale dining options. The neighborhood is known for its safe streets, accessibility, and a community-oriented vibe, attracting diners who appreciate a quieter, neighborhood-focused experience.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–21:30
Tuesday11:30–21:30
Wednesday11:30–21:30
Thursday11:30–22:00
Friday11:30–22:00
Saturday11:00–22:00
Sunday11:00–22:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →