Seemor
Nuovo York PizzaB-?Proceed Cautiously
105 E 9th St, New York, NY 10003
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.9/5 Google (1548 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Lively East Village slice shop with standout pesto pepperoni and solid Sicilian squares; best enjoyed in person, with delivery consistency and pricing value as common sticking points.
Why it gets a B-? for overall quality
⚠️ Review concerns: This assessment reflects moderate uncertainty due to questionable review patterns. See details in Authenticity Assessment. Nuovo York Pizza delivers solid neighborhood pizza with standout pesto pepperoni and Sicilian squares that justify its loyal following, but inconsistent execution between in-shop slices and delivery pies prevents a higher grade. Moderate authenticity concerns around review solicitation create uncertainty in the assessment, though the core in-person experience remains reliable and friendly. Best enjoyed as a casual dine-in stop rather than delivery option.
Restaurant Summary
A lively East Village slice shop where the counter hums and trays of squares catch your eye, Nuovo York Pizza wins fans for pesto pepperoni and crisp-corner Sicilians. "Hot, ready, and bigger than expected" captures the in-person vibe. However, there are moderate authenticity concerns suggesting some reviews may be solicited or influenced. The cooking leans classic NY-style with a few house signatures—think bright pesto, tangy vodka sauce, and a lighter-feeling spinach mushroom slice. The culinary approach is traditional with subtle twists: comforting pies first, creativity second. Best experiences are dine-in slices; delivery pies draw mixed feedback on thickness and toppings. For families, this is an easy win: cheese and pepperoni slices, bread bites, and calzones are kid-friendly, with gluten-free 12 in pies available. Seating is limited but turnover is quick; picky eaters will find familiar options, and prices stay in budget territory for a casual pizza night.
At a Glance
- Standout pesto pepperoni and solid Sicilian squares
- Fast counter service with friendly staff noted by many
- Delivery pies reported thinner or skimpier than in-person slices
- Specialty slice pricing feels high to some ($6 range)
- Moderate review authenticity concerns (alleged incentives, promotional outreach)
What Sets It Apart
- signature_pesto_pepperoni
- crispy_corner_sicilian
- heart_shaped_pizzas
What People Love
- Crispy corner Sicilian texture
- Balanced red sauce on classic slices
- Bright pesto with pepperoni pop
- Fast, easy counter experience
- Addictive Parmesan bread bites
Points of Concern
- Delivery consistency is mixed: several reports of thin, burnt, or under-topped pies compared to in-store slices
- Price perception: specialty slices around $6 feel steep to some given nearby competition
- Occasional brusque counter interactions and promo confusion reduced satisfaction for a few guests
- Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (alleged incentives, outreach, promotional language) which may not reflect typical diner experience
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$14-$22 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Share an 18 in cheese ($21) and add pepperoni for value versus individual specialty slices.
- Pair a couple of $6 specialty slices with $3.75 bread bites for a filling budget meal.
- Gluten-free diners: choose the 12 in GF margherita ($23) for a safer bet.
Perfect For
- Quick slice before or after a show
- Casual lunch near Washington Square
- Late-night comfort pizza stop
- Solo bite with a couple of specialty slices
Location Insights
Area: Bustling East Village block near NYU with steady student, local, and visitor foot traffic; casual late-night slice culture.
Safety: Generally safe with typical urban edge; occasional sketchy behavior mentioned but busy, well-trafficked streets.
Nearby: Close to Washington and Union Squares, NYU buildings, bars, cafes; high walkability and late-night demand.
East VillageThe East Village offers a diverse dining scene ranging from casual eateries and ethnic food spots to trendy bars and upscale restaurants. The social atmosphere is energetic and inclusive, attracting a mix of locals and visitors seeking authentic and innovative culinary experiences.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–03:00
Tuesday11:00–03:00
Wednesday11:00–03:00
Thursday11:00–03:00
Friday11:00–04:30
Saturday11:00–04:30
Sunday11:00–03:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →