Seemor
Downtown Manhattan › Financial District › Old Mates Pub
Old Mates PubB-?
170 John St, New York, NY 10038
· Pub, Australian restaurant
· Financial District
Lively Australian-themed pub with standout burgers, schnitzels, and trivia nights; great vibes but can be loud, crowded, and pricey with inconsistent service and tipping friction.
Why this grade
⚠️ Review concerns: This assessment reflects moderate uncertainty due to questionable review patterns. See details in Authenticity Assessment. Old Mates Pub delivers solid pub fare with standout items like its top-tier cheeseburger and crisp fish and chips, supported by a vibrant multi-level setting that excels for group gatherings.
One caveat: Pricing is high for pub fare; expect $25-$39 mains and $14-$16 desserts
What to order here
- Chicken Parma/Parmi
- Cheeseburger
- Fish and Chips
What stands out
- The burger delivers serious satisfaction
- Authentic-feeling Aussie memorabilia and vibe
- Trivia and DJ nights keep it lively
Opening Hours
Monday16:00–01:00
Tuesday16:00–01:00
Wednesday16:00–01:00
Thursday12:00–01:00
Friday12:00–02:00
Saturday12:00–02:00
Sunday12:00–23:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →