Seemor
Old Town BarB+Worth Trying
45 E 18th St, New York, NY 10003
· Pub, Gastropub, Restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (1799 reviews)
Takeout · Outdoor seating
Historic Flatiron pub with lively vibe, strong wings and burgers, fair-to-good value, but service warmth varies by staff and can be brusque when busy.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Old Town Bar delivers solid neighborhood gastropub performance anchored by exceptional historic setting and central location and reliable pub classics—wings, chili, and burgers that earn consistent praise. However, inconsistent execution on sides and occasional service tone issues prevent grade A territory. This is authentic New York pub character executed competently, ideal for casual drinks and groups, though not a destination for culinary distinction.
Restaurant Summary
Step through the door and the room feels authentic and lived-in—mahogany bar, tin ceiling, and a lively after-work buzz. Service at the bar is often quick and personable, with drinks landing fast even when packed. One guest summed it up: "It feels like real New York, the kind you want to stumble into." However, be aware that some review authenticity concerns are minimal here—most accounts feel genuine and photo-backed. The cooking leans classic pub—think crisp wings and hearty chili—with burgers that satisfy and a giant pretzel built for sharing. Execution is reliable, if not flashy: fries can wobble, but wings and chili carry the day. This is more about comforting standards than culinary fireworks, the kind of menu that pairs naturally with a pint in a historic room. Families fare well thanks to kid-friendly staples like burgers, tenders, fries, and pretzels; no specific kids menu, but plenty of simple picks. Value is decent for the area, though appetizers can feel high. If picky eaters stick to the basics, everyone should find something easy to enjoy.
At a Glance
- Lively, historic interior with genuine New York pub character
- Wings, chili, and burgers earn consistent praise
- Great for after-work drinks and casual groups; strong private event execution
- Service tone varies; a few reports of brusque or confrontational staff
- Starters can feel pricey; fries quality inconsistent
What Sets It Apart
- historic_pub_ambiance
- strong_wings_program
- upstairs_private_events
What People Love
- Old New York ambiance that feels real
- Crispy, generously portioned wings
- Fast, friendly bartenders who keep drinks moving
- Big soft pretzel perfect for sharing
Points of Concern
- Occasional reports of rude interactions with host or server, especially around seating flow
- Fried sides like fries can arrive soggy or overcooked
- Some items perceived as overpriced for bar food
- Review patterns show mostly authentic behavior but remain subject to normal platform noise
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$42-$58 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Start with the Giant German Pretzel (~$14, +$4 cheese) to share
- Pair a Cheeseburger (~$20.50) with coleslaw instead of fries if crispness matters
- Choose large wings (~$24) for best value and shareability
- Beyond Burger (~$18.75) plus House Salad (~$10.50) is a solid vegan combo
Perfect For
- Post-movie or pre-theater pints near Union Square
- Casual group hangouts in a historic pub
- Solo bar meal with quick service
- Private happy hours upstairs
Location Insights
Area: Busy Flatiron/Union Square corridor with offices, shops, and nightlife; strong after-work and weekend foot traffic.
Safety: Well-trafficked, generally safe with good lighting; standard NYC urban awareness applies.
Nearby: Near Union Square Park, tech offices, retailers, Regal theater, and major subway lines.
GramercyGramercy offers a refined dining scene with a mix of upscale restaurants, casual eateries, and historic taverns. The area is known for its quiet, tree-lined streets and a strong sense of community, attracting diners who appreciate a blend of sophistication and neighborhood charm.
Union Square SouthThis micro-neighborhood near Union Square Park is lively and diverse, featuring a mix of casual dining spots, food markets, and trendy cafes. It draws a younger crowd and those seeking quick, varied dining options in a vibrant urban setting.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–00:00
Tuesday11:30–00:30
Wednesday11:30–00:30
Thursday11:30–00:30
Friday11:30–01:00
Saturday11:30–00:30
Sunday12:00–22:30
Available: Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →