Seemor
Uptown › Yorkville › Omakase Shihou - Upper East Side (Lunch Available)
Omakase Shihou - Upper East Side (Lunch Available)A-
1586 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10028
· Japanese restaurant, Sushi restaurant
· Yorkville
High-quality, chef-led omakase with excellent fish and strong value at lunch; dinner is pricier but still competitive, with minor consistency and ambiance critiques.
The verdict
Omakase Shihou delivers exceptional food quality with pristine fish and thoughtful preparation, supported by attentive service that guides diners through each course. Mostly consistent execution and strong lunch value ($49) make it competitive with the area's better neighborhood omakase spots, though modest ambiance and occasional thawing concerns prevent it from reaching grade A territory.
One caveat: A few diners reported icy or poorly thawed fish on isolated visits
What to order
- King salmon
- Toro (otoro)
- Scallop (hotate)
What diners say
- Melt-in-mouth texture on top cuts
- Chef explanations that elevate the experience
- Thoughtful pacing and substitutions when requested
Opening Hours
Monday12:30–21:30
Tuesday12:30–21:30
Wednesday12:30–21:30
Thursday12:30–21:30
Friday12:30–21:30
Saturday12:30–21:30
Sunday12:30–21:30
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →