Seemor
Downtown Manhattan › Chelsea › O'Toole's Way
O'Toole's WayB+
518 W 30th St, New York, NY 10001
· Irish restaurant, American restaurant, Bar & grill
· Chelsea
Lively modern-Irish spot by the High Line with standout service, crowd-pleasing comfort dishes, and premium prices; great for drinks and groups, but policies and occasional rudeness reports can sour some visits.
Why this grade
O'Toole's Way delivers solid neighborhood dining with exceptional service warmth and above-average pub fare anchored by standouts like cottage pie and wings. However, inconsistent execution on core items and premium Hudson Yards pricing prevent a higher grade—it's a reliable pre-show or casual choice rather than a destination restaurant worth traveling for.
One caveat: Pricing feels high for portions; some mains small or fries extra
What to order here
- Dangerous Dave’s Dublin Dip
- Short Rib Cottage Pie
- Espresso Rubbed Chicken Wings
What stands out
- Friendly, proactive service that anticipates needs
- Comforting Irish-leaning dishes done with care
- Strong bar program with Guinness and cocktails
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–23:45
Tuesday11:00–23:45
Wednesday11:00–23:45
Thursday11:00–23:45
Friday11:00–23:45
Saturday11:00–23:45
Sunday11:00–22:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →