Seemor
Paul & Jimmy’s of GramercyB+Worth Trying
123 E 18th St, New York, NY 10003
· Italian restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (400 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Classic Gramercy Italian serving comforting pastas and old-school plates with warm vibes; quality is usually good, service can be uneven, and pricing sits on the premium side.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Paul & Jimmy's delivers solid neighborhood Italian dining with strong food quality in pastas and seafood, supported by a warm, classically renovated space and loyal local following. However, quality variation across visits—particularly in lasagna and gluten-free offerings—and occasional service inconsistencies prevent it from reaching higher territory. It's a reliable choice for traditional Italian comfort, especially for families and regulars seeking familiar flavors in a welcoming setting.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and classic with white linens and a refreshed retro glow, the kind of Gramercy spot where regulars greet staff by name. One diner noted, "It felt like being welcomed into a family home," while others praised the calm, conversation-friendly vibe. The cooking leans comforting and traditional rather than flashy: house-style pastas, crisp calamari, and old-school veal and chicken plates. It suits diners who want familiar flavors done with care, not theatrics. Most visits deliver satisfying portions and hearty sauces, though a few guests hit an off night with slower pacing or a drier lasagna. Families do well here thanks to kid-friendly classics like rigatoni alla vodka, chicken parm, and simple pastas. There is no listed kids menu, but servers will simplify sauces or go lighter on garlic, and gluten-free pasta exists though quality impressions vary.
At a Glance
- Classic Italian comfort with generous portions and big wine pours
- Cozy, renovated space that preserves old-school charm
- Service can be uneven with occasional slow pacing
- Some dishes inconsistent across visits (lasagna, gluten-free pasta)
- Good value via prix fixe and family-style options
What Sets It Apart
- third_generation_family_heritage
- refreshed_retro_interior
- prix_fixe_and_family_style
- garlic_free_accommodations
What People Love
- Feeling treated like family by longtime staff
- Rigatoni vodka and carbonara comfort factor
- Conversation-friendly room with classic touches
- Reliable celebratory spot for birthdays and milestones
Points of Concern
- Service inconsistency: a minority report slow or inattentive servers
- Occasional dish misses: lasagna dryness or bland GF pasta
- Wait times for mains can stretch on busy nights
- Pricing feels high for some items (desserts and GF substitutions)
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$55-$78 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Use the $33 prix fixe for a lighter, value-forward experience
- Pair a primi and shared secondi to balance cost and portion sizes
- Seafood mains at $32 offer strong quality-to-price ratio
Perfect For
- A relaxed date night near Union Square
- Family celebrations without loud crowds
- Neighborhood pasta cravings and wine
- Groups seeking prix fixe or family-style
Location Insights
Area: Leafy, residential-leaning Manhattan pocket with professionals and longtime locals; relaxed but polished dining scene.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit streets and steady foot traffic near Union Square and Gramercy Park.
Nearby: Near Union Square transit, offices, shops, bars; mix of neighborhood regulars and visitors.
GramercyGramercy is a quiet, upscale neighborhood known for its historic brownstones, the exclusive Gramercy Park, and a refined dining scene featuring a mix of classic American and contemporary restaurants. The area attracts diners looking for a more intimate and sophisticated atmosphere away from the busier parts of Manhattan.
Stuyvesant SquareStuyvesant Square is a smaller enclave within Gramercy characterized by its park, historic architecture, and a calm residential vibe. Dining here tends to be neighborhood-focused with casual eateries and boutique cafes serving locals and visitors seeking a relaxed environment.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–21:00
Tuesday12:00–22:00
Wednesday12:00–22:00
Thursday12:00–22:00
Friday12:00–23:00
Saturday12:00–23:00
Sunday12:00–21:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →