Neighborhood pizzeria with consistently loved pies, generous portions, and friendly service at fair prices, with occasional service hiccups and mixed feedback on vegan options.
Pizza Plus earns its A- grade through exceptional thin-crust pizza and comfort dishes paired with warm, attentive service that keeps locals returning for 35+ years. The reliable execution and fair pricing make it competitive with Park Slope's better neighborhood pizzerias, though occasional order hiccups and mixed vegan offerings prevent grade A territory.
One caveat: Order accuracy can slip (wrong toppings/cuts) and some late pickups reported