Seemor
Posto NYC Thin Crust PizzaB+Worth Trying
310 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10003
· Pizza restaurant, Cafe, Italian restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (644 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Neighborhood thin-crust spot with creative pies and strong happy hour value; food generally good, service can be slow and uneven.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Posto NYC delivers solid neighborhood pizza with excellent thin, crispy crust and creative toppings that keep locals returning, but quality varies—some pies emerge perfectly while others turn soggy or overcooked. Friendly staff are offset by slow service and infrequent check-ins, making this a relaxed hangout rather than a polished dining destination. The happy hour pricing is genuinely excellent, and the neighborhood vibe resonates with repeat customers, though it doesn't quite reach the consistency and service standards of grade A territory.
Restaurant Summary
This is a neighborhood hang where the crust is ultra thin and crisp, the vibe is relaxed, and locals actually linger. One diner summed it up: "The pie was light, crackly, and perfect for people watching outside." Service feels friendly but can be leisurely, so settle in rather than rush. The cooking leans classic Italian-American with creative topping combos rather than high-wire experiments. Think truffle-kissed mushroom pies, a hearty meat lover blend, and bright salads that balance the richness. Most nights the flavors land; occasional misses include a soggy margherita or an overbaked large pie. Families will do fine here: plain cheese, pepperoni, garlic bread, and simple salads make it kid friendly. Gluten-free crust exists but is not celiac-safe, and there is vegan cheese on request. If your crew wants adventurous toppings, you will find them; picky eaters can keep it classic.
At a Glance
- Super thin, crispy crust with flavorful topping combos
- Happy hour large cheese with bottle or pitcher offers standout value
- Service can be slow with infrequent check-ins
- Doneness and sogginess vary, especially on margherita
- Strong neighborhood feel with many repeat customers
What Sets It Apart
- super_thin_crust_style
- strong_happy_hour_pizza_deal
- customizable_pies_with_multiple_bases
What People Love
- That shatter-crisp crust that stays light
- Generous mushroom truffle notes on Shroomtown
- The HH deal that feels like a steal
- Relaxed, local vibe without tourist chaos
Points of Concern
- Service pacing is slow at times; expect longer gaps between check-ins
- Occasional overcooked or soggy pies reported, especially on large or margherita
- Personal pies feel small for price to some diners
- Review patterns show natural variation in quality; high highs and some misses
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$32-48 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Use custom pies to control moisture: bianco base with fewer wet toppings for extra crispness
- Families: plain cheese (Personal $13.50) plus garlic bread ($16) is an easy win
- Gluten-free crust available but not for celiac due to facility limitations
Perfect For
- Casual date night with wine and a shared pie
- Weeknight neighborhood dinner with friends
- Happy hour meetups on a budget
- Families wanting straightforward pizza night
Location Insights
Area: Residential-leaning Manhattan corridor with locals, students, and casual date-night traffic; relaxed neighborhood vibe.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit avenues with steady foot traffic; typical Manhattan awareness advised.
Nearby: Near Gramercy/Kips Bay apartments, small shops, and bars; convenient for pre-movie or casual meetups.
East VillageThe East Village offers a dynamic dining environment with a wide range of eateries from casual ethnic spots to trendy restaurants and bars. The social atmosphere is energetic and creative, often drawing a crowd interested in arts, music, and alternative culture.
Alphabet CityAlphabet City is known for its bohemian vibe, with many small bars, cafes, and innovative restaurants. It has a slightly edgier and more experimental dining scene compared to the broader East Village.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–21:30
Tuesday11:30–21:30
Wednesday11:30–21:30
Thursday11:30–22:00
Friday11:30–22:00
Saturday12:00–22:00
Sunday12:00–21:30
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →