Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Destination for thick Sicilian squares with crispy pepperoni cups; great slices, rushed counter service, long lines, little to no seating, and inconsistent temperature on busy days.
Prince Street Pizza delivers on its legendary Spicy Spring reputation with strong food quality and exceptional speed, earning solid neighborhood standing. However, quality wobbles during rush periods and cramped standing-room conditions prevent higher marks—the experience hinges on timing and willingness to eat standing up. A destination slice shop that excels at its core mission but falls short of premier dining reliability.
The tiny storefront hums with fast-paced energy as a line curls down Prince Street. Inside, you order at the counter and hope for a ledge; the mood is loud, efficient, and a bit chaotic. Many call the Spicy Spring a must, raving about those crispy pepperoni cups. One visitor summed it up: "The line felt long until that first crunchy bite." Expect standing room only and quick turnover. The cooking leans classic NYC slice shop with a Sicilian focus, not flashy but assertive. The culinary approach is elevated traditional: sturdy squares, spicy vodka sauce, and occasional hot honey and ricotta flourishes. When slices are hot and well-toasted, the texture balance can sing; at rush or in delivery, temperature and doneness wobble, so order reheated and eat promptly for the best shot at that crisp-meets-fluffy bite. Families will find kid-friendly choices like plain cheese and pepperoni, and portions are filling. The catch: no real seating and a loud, crowded counter. If you have a stroller or need downtime, consider taking slices to Elizabeth Street Garden nearby. Vegan and gluten-free options exist on paper, but reviews suggest mixed execution—stick to simpler toppings for picky eaters.
Area: Trendy SoHo/Nolita corridor with heavy foot traffic, shopping, and visitors; fast-paced and lively.
Safety: Busy, well-trafficked commercial blocks; generally safe with constant foot traffic and good lighting.
Nearby: Boutiques, cafes, Elizabeth Street Garden nearby; tourist draws and late-night crowds.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →