Seemor
Reg'z New York PizzaA-Worth Trying
28-17 36th Ave, Astoria, NY 11106
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.7/5 Google (481 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Neighborhood slice shop with standout NY-style pies, friendly service, and surprising Mexican options; great value with occasional service hiccups.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Reg'z New York Pizza delivers exceptional food quality with crispy, flavorful slices and warm, accommodating service that define neighborhood pizza excellence. Occasional consistency lapses and a functional but unremarkable setting prevent grade A territory, though generous portions at budget prices and strong local loyalty cement its standing as a respected Astoria institution worth visiting.
Restaurant Summary
This is a classic Astoria slice shop where the pies take center stage and the vibe is friendly and unpretentious. Many diners rave about the thin, crisp crust and standout sauces, with one remarking that the Sicilian was "outrageous" and the staff were warm and accommodating. The space is casual and quick-moving, a true neighborhood gem. The cooking skews traditional New York with a few twists: think Margherita, Upside Down Sicilian, and Pep Diavolo, alongside Mexican-inspired slices and a side menu of tacos and burritos. The culinary approach leans elevated traditional (innovation level 5.6): classic flavors first, with occasional spicy or hot-honey nudges rather than theatrics. Portions are generous and pricing is very wallet-friendly. Families do well here. Kids gravitate to cheese slices and garlic knots, and staff have been noted helping a child through a tough moment. The menu is packed with familiar options—plain cheese, chicken parm heroes, mozzarella sticks, fries—so even selective eaters find something. No kids menu is needed given the breadth of simple choices.
At a Glance
- Excellent NY-style slices with crisp crust and flavorful sauces
- Generous portions at budget prices
- Friendly, accommodating staff and owner presence
- Occasional order/delivery mistakes and undercooked pie reports
- Limited parking; late-night slice freshness can vary
What Sets It Apart
- mix_of_pizza_and_mexican
- grandma_and_upside_down_sicilian
- owner_hospitality
What People Love
- The crispy yet foldable crust
- Hearty Sicilian and grandma pies
- Warm, personal service from the owner
- Value pricing with big portions
- Pepperoni cups and spicy Diavolo sauce
Points of Concern
- A few hygiene and food safety complaints tied to counter handling and late-night slices; appears isolated but noted
- Some delivery delays and wrong-order incidents with mixed apologies
- Pricing discrepancy reported on a drink; management acknowledged in replies
- Review patterns show minimal templating in owner responses but not review manipulation
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$18-28 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Pair a $4.50 Margherita slice with $1.50 garlic knots for a budget snack
- Feeding a group? One Sicilian or Grandma pie ($24-$28) plus wings ($9-$12) covers 3-4 people affordably
- Vegetarian diners: White Mushroom ($22) or Reg'z Veggie Sicilian (no-cheese, $28)
Perfect For
- A quick, satisfying slice run
- Casual family dinner without breaking the bank
- Group hang after events or practice
- Out-of-towners seeking a classic NY slice
Location Insights
Area: Lively Astoria corridor with mixed residential and small businesses; casual, local-focused foot traffic.
Safety: Generally safe with steady foot traffic; late-night feels active and well lit per reviews.
Nearby: Near other pizzerias, cafes, and transit along 36th Ave; delivery demand appears high.
AstoriaAstoria is a lively, culturally rich neighborhood with a strong Greek heritage alongside a growing mix of other ethnicities. The dining scene is eclectic, featuring traditional Greek tavernas, modern cafes, and international eateries. The area is popular for its casual yet trendy atmosphere, attracting locals and visitors seeking authentic and affordable dining experiences.
Ditmars SteinwayDitmars Steinway is a sub-area within Astoria known for its bustling commercial strip along Steinway Street and Ditmars Boulevard, featuring a concentration of restaurants, bars, and shops. It has a friendly, neighborhood feel with a mix of old-school establishments and newer trendy spots, making it a popular dining destination.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday10:00–21:30
Tuesday10:00–21:30
Wednesday10:00–21:30
Thursday10:00–21:30
Friday10:00–21:30
Saturday10:00–21:30
Sunday10:00–21:30
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →