Seemor
Rome to Brooklyn, pizza & panzerottiA-Worth Trying
587 Manhattan Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.8/5 Google (142 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Creative, high-quality grandma and specialty slices with friendly counter service and fair pricing; best for pizza lovers who enjoy inventive toppings and a casual vibe.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Rome to Brooklyn earns its A- grade through exceptional food quality—particularly standout vodka pesto burrata and grandma slices with crisp, light crust—paired with warm, attentive service and clean, airy neighborhood appeal. Reliable execution and fair pricing for premium ingredients position it competitively with the area's better slice destinations, though occasional delivery inconsistencies and a creative rather than classic focus prevent grade A territory.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels open and airy with that neighborhood slice-shop ease—clean counters, plenty of seats, and friendly faces behind the line. Reviews gush that slices are "light yet crunchy" and the staff is warm and helpful. It is the kind of place you swing by after the park or before a show and end up staying for a second slice. The culinary approach leans creative Italian with a grandma-slice focus: vodka pesto burrata, rosemary potato with pancetta, truffle mushroom, even blueberry with pancetta. It is elevated traditional rather than flashy, where premium ingredients and crisp bakes matter more than theatrics. Fans of classic pepperoni or a saucy Margherita are just as happy as those chasing unique toppings. Families do well here. There are kid-pleasing options like plain cheese and Margherita, along with salads and simple pastas around $14. If your crew includes picky eaters, stick to classics; the creative pies are fantastic, but some combos skew adventurous for little palates.
At a Glance
- Standout vodka pesto burrata and grandma slices with crisp, light crust
- Friendly counter service and clean, airy seating
- Fair prices for premium toppings and generous portions
- Delivery can be inconsistent with toppings sliding
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- inventive_grandma_slices
- neighborhood_loyalty
- premium_ingredients_at_fair_prices
What People Love
- Crispy yet airy crust that stays light
- Vodka sauce and burrata combo magic
- Unique toppings that still feel balanced
- Friendly staff that remembers regulars
- Clean space with plenty of seating
Points of Concern
- Delivery issues reported with toppings sliding off and oily boxes on a few orders
- One complaint about truffle oil quality affecting mushroom slice flavor
- Pricing for specialty pies can add up if ordering whole, though slices remain fair
- Limited options for conservative palates or picky eaters
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$22-$32 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Vegetarians have many choices: Margherita, Bianco, Vegetariana, Wild Mushroom & Truffle, Pear Gorgonzola & Hot Honey.
- Vegans can order the Vegan pie (marinara, grilled veg, olives, basil, EVOO).
- Value play: mix one specialty slice with a classic cheese for balance and cost control.
Perfect For
- Pre-show slice before Warsaw
- Casual weeknight dinner with friends
- Post-park snack near McCarren
- Solo quick bite with seating
Location Insights
Area: Trendy Greenpoint stretch near McCarren Park; mix of locals, families, and weekend crowds.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked corridor with good lighting and steady foot traffic.
Nearby: Close to McCarren Park, neighborhood bars, cafes, and venues like Warsaw; strong evening footfall.
GreenpointGreenpoint offers a dynamic dining scene blending traditional Polish eateries with trendy cafes, craft breweries, and innovative restaurants. The neighborhood maintains a friendly, community-oriented atmosphere with a mix of old-school charm and modern urban culture, making it popular for casual dining and social gatherings.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–23:00
Tuesday11:00–23:00
Wednesday11:00–23:00
Thursday11:00–23:00
Friday11:00–00:00
Saturday11:00–00:00
Sunday11:00–23:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →