Seemor
Sal & Paul's PizzeriaB+Worth Trying
1686 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (398 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Classic neighborhood slice shop with big, tasty pies, friendly counter service, and kid-pleasing slushies; best enjoyed in person and great value.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Sal & Paul's Pizzeria delivers solid food quality with classic NY-style slices, legendary garlic knots, and exceptional value that keeps locals returning. Friendly counter service and reliable execution support the grade, though modest space appeal and occasional delivery inconsistencies prevent higher standing. This is dependable neighborhood pizza done well, best enjoyed fresh at the counter.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels old-school and bustling, the kind of counter where neighbors pop in for a quick slice and a chat. Lines can form at lunch, but they move, and a staffer might even ask if you want a Sicilian corner or middle. One regular put it best: "This is my must-stop when I am in the area." The cooking leans classic New York slice shop more than trend-chasing: thin pies with a chewy edge, square Sicilians, and the crowd-pleasing buffalo slice. Garlic knots get near-mythic praise, and portions are generous for the price. It is dependable comfort, best enjoyed fresh from the counter rather than through a delivery bag. For families, this is kid-friendly and low-stress. Cheese or grandma slices, chicken tenders, and zeppole keep it simple, while the colorful slushy fountain is a slam dunk. No kids menu needed—just order slices and share an extra-large pie if you are feeding a crew.
At a Glance
- Big, tasty NY-style slices with reliable crust and balance
- Excellent value for pies, slices, and heroes
- Friendly counter service; locals return often
- Delivery via apps can be messy and less consistent
- Lines at lunch; occasional order mistakes under rush
What Sets It Apart
- legendary_garlic_knots
- kid_pleasing_slushies
- large_value_slices
What People Love
- Satisfying NY-style crust and sauce balance
- Legendary garlic knots
- Buffalo slice with real zip
- Kid-pleasing slushy fountain
- Consistent value for the money
Points of Concern
- Delivery orders can arrive messy or overly cheesy; in-person quality is better
- Occasional order errors during rush (wrong hero, missing sauce)
- Pricing confusion vs. slice size once noted; ask before ordering if uncertain
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$14-$22 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For vegetarians, choose Grandma or Margarita pie; for hearty appetites, add a chicken parm hero; families can split an extra-large cheese pie for value.
Perfect For
- Quick lunch between errands
- Feeding a group with budget pies
- After-school slice and slushy
- Casual weeknight takeout
Location Insights
Area: Busy Brownsville retail corridor with everyday foot traffic and neighborhood shoppers; practical, no-frills vibe.
Safety: Generally fine during the day with steady foot traffic; standard urban awareness advised at night.
Nearby: Pitkin Ave shops, schools, bus routes; convenient for grab-and-go and lunch crowds.
East New YorkThe dining scene in East New York is largely composed of casual, family-owned eateries, pizzerias, and small ethnic restaurants reflecting the diverse local community. The social atmosphere is neighborhood-oriented and informal, with a focus on affordable, hearty meals rather than upscale dining. Safety and accessibility have improved but can vary block by block.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–19:00
Tuesday11:30–19:00
Wednesday11:30–19:00
Thursday11:30–19:00
Friday11:30–19:00
Saturday11:30–19:00
Sunday11:30–19:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →