Seemor

Sal & Paul's PizzeriaB+

1686 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11212 · Pizza restaurant · Brownsville

Classic neighborhood slice shop with big, tasty pies, friendly counter service, and kid-pleasing slushies; best enjoyed in person and great value.

Why this grade

Sal & Paul's Pizzeria delivers solid food quality with classic NY-style slices, legendary garlic knots, and exceptional value that keeps locals returning. Friendly counter service and reliable execution support the grade, though modest space appeal and occasional delivery inconsistencies prevent higher standing. This is dependable neighborhood pizza done well, best enjoyed fresh at the counter.

One caveat: Delivery orders can arrive messy or overly cheesy; in-person quality is better

What to order here

What stands out

Opening Hours

Monday11:30–19:00 Tuesday11:30–19:00 Wednesday11:30–19:00 Thursday11:30–19:00 Friday11:30–19:00 Saturday11:30–19:00 Sunday11:30–19:00
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →