A memorable subterranean Midtown pizzeria with excellent pizza and a distinctive punk-retro setting, but reserve ahead and expect tight seating, occasional service lapses, and a genuinely premium price for a casual pie.
See No Evil Pizza delivers strong food quality and welcoming service in a distinctive subterranean punk-themed setting near Times Square, making it a reliable pre-theater choice. Inconsistent execution on doneness and topping precision prevents a higher grade, and tight, hot quarters limit comfort despite the atmospheric appeal.
See No Evil Pizza is exactly the kind of Midtown surprise people remember: descend through a subway entrance near Times Square and you land in a compact, punk-retro room where the energy is lively and the pizzas arrive quickly when the operation is clicking. Diners describe it as a hidden New York experience, with one memorable verdict amounting to “a serious pizza destination in an utterly bizarre location.” The room is atmospheric, but it is also genuinely tight, warm, and sometimes loud. The cooking is Italian-inspired and pizza-led, with a strong crust-and-sauce foundation plus more adventurous combinations such as Johnny Peppers, Hell Pie, Bank Robber, and Pineapple Express. Margherita and pepperoni are the safest bets; the menu also rewards curious eaters with vegetables, preserved fish, burrata, inventive salads, and wine pairings. Most reviews find the food excellent, though a minority report soggy or cold pies, uneven toppings, and a price that feels high once drinks or gratuity enter the picture. Families can make this work, especially before a show: reviewers report children enjoying Margherita and pepperoni, and the menu includes familiar cheese, pepperoni, and meatball pizzas plus soft serve and tiramisu. However, the tight, noisy room and stairs are not ideal for every child or mobility need, and the menu is not fully accommodating for vegan or celiac diners. Reserve ahead, arrive with realistic expectations about space, and choose straightforward pies for picky eaters.
Area vibe: Busy, tourist- and theatre-focused central Manhattan area with dense commercial activity.
Safety: Generally busy and well-lit with heavy foot traffic, though pickpocketing and congestion are common; stay alert after late shows.
What's nearby: Close to Broadway theatres, Times Square, Rockefeller Center, major subway lines and hotel corridors.
Start with a classic Margherita or Pepperoni, or go more adventurous with Johnny Peppers, Hell Pie, or Pineapple Express.
Plan for a memorable but cramped subway-station setting, with reservations advisable and a few important caveats about noise, gratuity, and dietary needs.
Expect a punk-retro pizza room in a subway entrance, where memorable energy comes with tight seating, heat, and occasional noise.