Inventive Italian-Asian fusion with standout duck ragù and creative chicken parm; polished service and cocktails, premium pricing, with mixed experiences on busy nights and occasional execution lapses.
Sesamo delivers solid neighborhood dining through strong food quality and exceptional service attentiveness, with creative Italian-Asian fusion and a loyal following. However, inconsistent execution on busy nights—particularly with fish doneness and seasoning—prevents grade A territory, while a recent food safety concern adds caution. The cozy West Side location and knowledgeable staff make it competitive with respected local favorites, though execution reliability needs strengthening.
On 10th Avenue, this spot blends Italian comfort with Asian flair in a room that feels cozy and welcoming. Reviews rave about the team by name, and one diner said service was 10 out of 10, with thoughtful recommendations and quick plate clears. However, execution can wobble on busy nights, and pricing changes have surprised a few guests. The cooking leans contemporary fusion, not classic trattoria. Expect miso in salmon, tempura on chicken parm, and Calabrian heat in bucatini. The culinary approach is creative and produce-driven: bold flavors and cross-cultural touches rather than safe tradition. Fans praise duck ragù and the crunchy, reimagined chicken parm; detractors sometimes find sauces salty or fish over/undercooked. Families will find a warm and accommodating staff, with familiar anchors like pastas, chicken parm, and a burger for less adventurous eaters. There is at least one vegan main and several vegetarian options, though the fusion tilt may challenge picky palates. No explicit kids menu noted; consider lunch or earlier seatings for the calmest experience.
Area vibe: Lively West Side blocks near Broadway; pre-theater traffic, neighborhood locals, and bar scene.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked evenings; typical Midtown West foot traffic and lighting.
What's nearby: Near Broadway theaters, 9th/10th Ave dining corridors, residential walk-ups, bars.