Seemor

Simple NYCB+Worth Trying

Name: Simple NYC
Address: 109 Eldridge St, New York, NY 10002, New York, United States
Rating: 4.7

109 Eldridge St, New York, NY 10002 · Poke bar, Restaurant, Salad shop · 4.7/5 Google (342 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout

Excellent poke and Japanese-influenced bowls in a tiny mostly-takeout spot; great freshness and portions but sauce can be heavy and seating is extremely limited.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Simple NYC delivers strong food quality with fresh fish and generous portions that justify its loyal following, though consistency shows occasional variation in sauce application and recent chicken texture concerns. The cramped seating and counter-service format limit ambiance appeal, and mixed recent feedback on execution prevents a higher grade despite solid fundamentals and fair value for the neighborhood.

Restaurant Summary

This pocket-size LES spot runs on fresh fish and fast hands, turning out big, satisfying bowls from a space with barely a few seats. Expect counter ordering, quick handoffs, and the occasional line. One guest summed it up: "Best poke I had in NYC—fresh and filling," while another cautioned that sauce can run heavy if you do not ask for it lighter. The cooking leans Japanese-influenced poke and homestyle bowls rather than showy fusion—think miso-kissed salmon, ahi tuna with togarashi, and gyudon with a sunny egg. Portions are generous for the price, and add-ons like jumbo crabmeat push it into premium territory if you want to splurge. Most experiences praise freshness and balance, though a few recent diners wished for lighter sauce and noted a one-off rude cashier. Families can make it work if you are comfortable with counter service and tight quarters. Kids who like simple flavors may enjoy cooked salmon, grilled chicken, plain rice, or tofu, but there is no dedicated kids menu. If your crew prefers classic comfort over seafood, consider the teriyaki chicken bento, though recent reviews were mixed on chicken texture.

At a Glance

Fresh fish and generous portions praised by regulars
Fair pricing for NYC with premium add-ons available
Sauce can be heavy unless requested light or on the side
Extremely limited seating; mostly a takeout play
Mixed feedback on chicken texture in recent posts

What Sets It Apart

tiny_neighborhood_gem
poke_plus_japanese_bentos
generous_portions_at_fair_prices

What People Love

Fresh-tasting tuna and salmon
Hearty, filling bowls
Kind counter staff and neighborhood feel
Reliable quality over multiple visits

Points of Concern

Sauce occasionally over-applied leading to soggy rice
Tiny space with 2-3 seats; dine-in comfort is limited
One-off rude cashier experience reported
Recent cluster of complaints about fatty or greasy chicken pieces

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost$19-$27 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Choose raw tuna or miso salmon bowls for best freshness-to-price ratio
Add rice side ($2) for budget fullness
Vegan diners: miso or pan-seared tofu pokes are reliable picks

Perfect For

Quick solo lunch between errands
Healthy takeout before a night out
Casual weeknight bowl at home
Post-gym protein fix

Location Insights

Area: Trendy Lower East Side block with casual eateries, cafes, and boutique shops; strong takeout demand.

Safety: Generally safe, busy pedestrian traffic; typical NYC street environment.

Nearby: Near bars, galleries, and apartments; popular for quick lunch and late bites.

Lower East SideThe Lower East Side is known for its eclectic dining scene ranging from traditional Jewish delis and old-school eateries to trendy new restaurants and bars. It has a lively, youthful atmosphere with a mix of historic charm and modern gentrification, attracting a diverse crowd interested in food, nightlife, and culture.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:00–18:00 Tuesday11:00–18:00 Wednesday11:00–18:00 Thursday11:00–18:00 Friday11:00–18:00 Saturday Sunday

Available: Delivery, Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →