Seemor
Smith Street PizzaB+Worth Trying
311 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
· Pizza restaurant, Fine dining restaurant, Italian restaurant
· 4.7/5 Google (220 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Strong neighborhood slice shop with standout dough and popular specialty slices; service can falter on phones and deliveries but dine-in slices are a safe, tasty bet.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Smith Street Pizza delivers excellent food quality with its signature crisp-chewy crust and balanced sauce, earning consistent praise from repeat visitors. However, service inconsistencies—particularly phone responsiveness and delivery delays—prevent a higher grade, while solid consistency and fair pricing make it a reliable neighborhood choice for quality slices rather than a destination pizzeria.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and bustling in that classic Smith Street way, with a counter full of glistening pies and a small backyard when weather cooperates. Service at the counter is often friendly and quick, and several locals call this their new go-to. One diner summed up the vibe: "Crisp snap, chewy dough, and sauce that tastes right." However, phone responsiveness and delivery can be spotty based on several reports. The cooking leans NY slice tradition with smart crowd-pleasers—think vodka pie, buffalo chicken, grandma squares, and cup-pepperoni. The culinary approach leans elevated traditional: familiar flavors done with care rather than flashy fusion. If you want a reliable slice with better-than-average crust and generous toppings, this is easy to recommend; stick to pizza over the broader entrees for the strongest showing. Families do well here: pizza by the slice, chicken fingers, fries, and heroes mean kids will find something. A vegan marinara option and several vegetarian pies help with mixed groups. Backyard seating gives parents a breather when open, making it a low-stress choice for casual family meals.
At a Glance
- Crisp-chewy crust and balanced sauce win consistent praise
- Vodka and buffalo chicken slices are fan favorites
- Phone and delivery service can be unreliable at times
- Non-pizza entrees receive mixed feedback
- Fair pricing for quality in a prime neighborhood
What Sets It Apart
- backyard_seating
- standout_vodka_slice
- neighborhood_regulars_vibe
What People Love
- That crisp snap before a chewy bite
- Loaded specialty slices that still stay balanced
- Neighborhood vibe with friendly counter staff
- Backyard seating that feels like a bonus
Points of Concern
- Phone lines sometimes go unanswered; online orders may hiccup
- Delivery delays reported up to 1 hour 45 minutes at peaks
- Occasional counter rudeness or inflexibility cited by a few diners
- Chicken Marsala and some non-pizza entrees called bland by some
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$20-$34 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose a whole pie ($24-$34) if feeding 3-4; otherwise pair two slices ($8-$12) with garlic knots ($3.50) for value.
- Veggie diners: try White Pie or Popeye; dairy-free: Marinara pie (no cheese).
Perfect For
- Quick slice before a movie or park stroll
- Casual family dinner without reservations
- Takeout pies for a kids birthday or game night
- Solo lunch with a backyard seat on nice days
Location Insights
Area: Charming brownstone blocks with a neighborhood vibe; mix of families, professionals, and weekend strollers.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked commercial strip with good lighting and steady foot traffic.
Nearby: Smith Street corridor with cafes, boutiques, bars; near Carroll Park and several subway lines.
Carroll GardensCarroll Gardens offers a charming, community-oriented dining scene with a mix of traditional Italian eateries, trendy cafes, and upscale restaurants. The neighborhood is known for its tree-lined streets, historic brownstones, and a relaxed yet lively social atmosphere that attracts both locals and visitors.
Gowanus BorderThe area near 311 Smith St borders the Gowanus neighborhood, known for its industrial roots and emerging arts scene. Dining here often features innovative, eclectic options with a focus on artisanal and locally sourced ingredients, appealing to a hip, adventurous crowd.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–22:00
Tuesday11:30–22:00
Wednesday11:30–22:00
Thursday11:30–22:00
Friday11:30–22:00
Saturday11:30–22:00
Sunday11:30–21:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →