Seemor
S&P LunchA-Worth Trying
174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010
· Restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (549 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Beloved Flatiron deli-diner serving standout pastrami, tuna melts, and breakfast plates with quick counter energy; occasional service misfires and crowding, but strong overall value for classic NYC fare.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
S&P Lunch delivers exceptional pastrami and tuna melt execution with authentic Flatiron luncheonette charm, earning solid A-grade standing. Service efficiency is strong, though occasional rudeness and cramped quarters with peak-hour waits prevent higher distinction. A reliable neighborhood classic that exceeds typical deli standards without reaching destination-restaurant status.
Restaurant Summary
Step into a slice of Flatiron history where the counter hums, coffee refills land fast, and the grill perfumes the room with pastrami spice. The vibe is old-school and bustling, lines move quickly, and staff often feel efficient and friendly. As one diner put it, "the pastrami on rye was incredibly flavorful and balanced." Expect crowds and the occasional rough edge, but the spirit is classic NYC luncheonette. The cooking leans traditional deli comfort more than showy, with a focus on pastrami and corned beef, the much-loved tuna melt, and breakfast staples like pancakes, omelettes, and matzo ball soup. Flavors are sturdy and satisfying rather than flashy; portions are sensible, not tourist-deli huge. If you crave nostalgic, no-frills plates done right, this is your lane. Families do well here thanks to kid-friendly classics: pancakes, grilled cheese, burgers, hot dogs, fries, and simple eggs. The menu offers familiar sides and soups, though adventurous items like borscht or sardines may not suit every palate. Space is tight and waits happen, so arrive off-peak if visiting with kids and strollers.
At a Glance
- Standout pastrami and tuna melt with nostalgic diner charm
- Fast-moving counter vibe ideal for solo diners
- Crowded, narrow space with waits at peak times
- Inconsistent service tone reported, especially at host/manager level
- Portions are sensible, not giant; some perceive lower value vs overstuffed delis
What Sets It Apart
- heritage_luncheonette_ambience
- balanced_pastrami_not_overstuffed
- strong_counter_for_solos
What People Love
- Flavor-packed pastrami with balanced ratio
- Buttery, crisp-edged tuna melt on rye
- Quick, efficient service once seated
- Nostalgic luncheonette energy and music
Points of Concern
- Peak-time waits and cramped seating can frustrate
- Occasional rude or inattentive interactions at the door or register
- Inconsistency: fries texture, pancake doneness, dense matzo ball
- Review patterns show polarized views on portion-to-price compared to tourist delis
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$28-$42 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- For kids: pancakes ($10) or grilled cheese ($8)
- For lighter eaters: Garden Salad ($10) with a scoop of tuna/egg ($12)
- For hearty deli fans: Pastrami ($16) with onion rings ($6)
Perfect For
- A classic NYC deli lunch near Flatiron
- Solo counter meals with quick turnaround
- Casual brunch with diner staples
- Out-of-town friends seeking old-school vibes
Location Insights
Area: Bustling Flatiron corridor with office crowds, tourists, and locals; daytime-heavy foot traffic and classic NYC street energy.
Safety: Well-trafficked, well-lit commercial area; feels safe with steady pedestrian presence.
Nearby: Near Flatiron Building, Madison Square Park, retail corridors, offices; strong lunch demand and steady weekend visitors.
Flatiron DistrictThe Flatiron District offers a dynamic dining scene with a mix of upscale restaurants, casual eateries, and trendy cafes. The area is lively during weekdays with office workers and tech employees, while weekends attract tourists and locals enjoying the vibrant urban atmosphere.
NoMadNoMad (North of Madison Square Park) is known for its boutique hotels, stylish bars, and innovative dining options, attracting a trendy crowd seeking upscale yet approachable culinary experiences.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday08:00–17:00
Tuesday08:00–17:00
Wednesday08:00–17:00
Thursday08:00–22:00
Friday08:00–22:00
Saturday09:00–22:00
Sunday09:00–22:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →